Olde Dutch

Reviews

• PM

  Peggy Mintun

  Nov 15, 2025
  5.0
  Definitely an old farm house vibe crossed with an old Bob Evans before they went corporate. The chicken on the salad bar was freaking huge. Like the leg was at least 4 times bigger. I ate it hoping the science they used would enhance me but not in a vile way. Anyway, I’ll be back because $15 is a bargain. No photos.
• HL

  Henry GaFai Lee

  Nov 11, 2025
  5.0
  One of my favorite gems in Ohio to swing by with friends and family. Enjoy the BUFFET which includes a variety of home cooked foods like stuffing, broccoli cheddar bake, sweet potato casserole, baked fish, roast beef, giant fries chicken pieces, green bean casserole, and all the dishes you’d find at a traditional Thanksgiving dinner. Your buffet experience includes a robust salad bar, choice of several soups like enchilada soup, potato soup, and beef stew (all three were decision!) and a full lineup of pies! For a $1.99 extra, they’ll even throw a scoop of ice cream on top upon request. The perfect spot for a large or small group, or even a solo lunch or dinner, family-friendly atmosphere, very clean (they even provide hand sanitizer and gloves next to the food), cute gift shop, conveniently located right off the freeway after some good hiking in Hocking County or looking for antique treasures next door, or between Sunday church and grocery shopping at Weavers Market or Walmart across the street. Special shoutout to our amazing server Kayleigh. Her smile is like sunshine and made us feel welcome even before I knew she was taking care of us. Sorry boys, I asked, and she’s already taken :)
• SB

  Sally Bricker

  Nov 7, 2025
  4.0
  There was good variety of food choices on the buffet. Some of the meat (turkey, beef) was a little dry but overall, the food tasted fine. We came right when it opened for the day so it wasn't crowded, but when it got busy a short time later, there was a large line at the buffet. Seems like there should have been another buffet for the size of the restaurant. The pie for dessert seemed like it was store bought which was disappointing. So, not a bad place to eat, but nothing that would make me want to come back there again.
• RS

  Robbie Scott

  Nov 5, 2025
  5.0
  Buffets and I have a love/hate relationship. I love to eat large amounts of food, but at a buffet the quality always suffers. As far as a buffet, this is one of the best I've had. It is an investment, but I literally liked everything I tried (and I tried a lot of things) and then there was pie for dessert, yum yum. There are bigger buffets out there, and there is better food, too, but I really enjoyed this, and plan to come back, though only occasionally, due to my lack of willpower and all that ..
• CM

  Cortney Mack

  Nov 5, 2025
  5.0
  Drove from Columbus to have lunch, we love a good buffet. The food was great. Our server was awesome. The place was so clean. They were quick to replace food once it was emptied / almost emptied. Only downfall was when we looked the restaurant up it implied there were goats near the property you could pet / go in with like a petting zoo and when we questioned about it we were told to go to the ice cream shop in the same parking lot. The goats pen wasn't going to be opened until 5pm l.

Frequently Asked Questions About Olde Dutch