Customers generally praised the food for being delicious and well-prepared, though some noted inconsistencies in freshness and portion sizes.
Service
While many reviews highlighted friendly and attentive service, there were complaints about slow service and mistakes with orders.
Pricing
Several customers felt that the prices were high for the portion sizes and quality, with some mentioning unexpected charges.
Atmosphere
The restaurant is appreciated for its festive atmosphere and friendly environment, although some noted issues with cleanliness and noise levels.
SA
Stevie Armbrester
2 days ago
3.0
Stay blessed & continue putting your foot in those meals😉🙏🏾😋
RM
Robert Mackey
Jan 3, 2026
5.0
Maybe not fancy, maybe not "authentic," but im no judge (never been to Mexico); but my family loves it. The food always hits the spot. Service is swift and friendly. Prices are totally reasonable. What's not to like?
DS
David Scheck
Dec 24, 2025
2.0
It's so over priced for what you get. Absolutely insane. You can get better food for half the price at so many different places. I don't know why people still go here.
BT
Bee Tia
Dec 22, 2025
1.0
So I come here and tried to support their establishment because I heard ice was in the city
( Columbus ) and I feel really bad for them I used my debt card to pay for my lunch came up to $88.00 why two days later I get a notification from my bank that someone tried to run my account at a Mexican supermarket and a La Fiesta Toledo restaurant so they had to take a picture of my debit card… BLACK PEOPLE STAY OUT OF THESE MEXICAN RESTAURANT’S THEY GOT ICE COMING AFTER THEM AND THEY STILL HAVE IN THIER HEART TO DO HATEFUL THINGS TO US SMH A SAD SHAME.
KL
Kameran Loya
Dec 16, 2025
5.0
Food always good people are a little standoffish, but I think that’s because of the language barrier but very nice people overall
Frequently Asked Questions About El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant
What are the operating hours of El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant?
El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant is open daily from 11:00 AM. Monday to Thursday, it closes at 10:00 PM. On Friday and Saturday, it closes at 10:30 PM, and on Sunday, it closes at 9:30 PM.
Does El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant offer delivery and pickup services?
Yes, El Vaquero offers both in-store pickup and delivery services.
Where is El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant located?
El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant is located at 1780 Hilliard Rome Rd, Hilliard, OH 43026, United States.
Where can I find El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant's menu online?
You can view the menu at https://vaquerorestaurant.com/menu.
How can I place an order from El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant?
Orders can be placed online at https://vaquerorestaurant.com/menu.
What type of cuisine does El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant serve?
El Vaquero serves Mexican cuisine including tacos, burritos, and Mexican tortas. It is also a family-friendly and vegetarian-friendly restaurant with catering services.
Is there a coffee shop near El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant?
Yes, Tim Hortons and Biggby Coffee are nearby coffee shops where you can grab a coffee before or after your meal at El Vaquero.
Are there other dining options close to El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant?
Nearby dining options include Skyline Chili, Texas Roadhouse, KFC, BIBIBOP Asian Grill, Charleys Cheesesteaks and Wings, Frisch's Big Boy, and Chipotle Mexican Grill.
Can I go shopping near El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant?
Yes, you can visit nearby stores such as Michaels for crafts, dressbarn for clothing, Bed Bath & Beyond for home goods, Famous Footwear for shoes, Karen's Hallmark Shop for gifts, and Mattress Firm for furniture.
Are there any automotive services near El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant?
Yes, Firestone Complete Auto Care and an EVgo electric vehicle charging station are nearby for your automotive needs.