Mixed reviews on pizza quality; some customers enjoyed it while others found it undercooked or lacking flavor.
Customer Service
Customer service experiences vary widely, with some praising the staff while others report rudeness and poor service.
Atmosphere
The atmosphere is described as shabby and dive-bar-like, which detracts from the overall dining experience.
Convenience and Variety
The business is appreciated for its convenience store offerings and variety of food options, including pizza, subs, and fishing supplies.
MT
Michelle Turner
Dec 18, 2025
5.0
Absolutely love the pizza sub!!
JF
Jamie Frost
Dec 13, 2025
5.0
Pizza was really good. Only complaint is the crust wasn't crusty at all. more like a bread instead of a crust
JP
John Pugh
Nov 21, 2025
1.0
Im not surprised it's hard to find really good pizza in central ohio sauce was tastless dough undercooked the pepperoni tasteless. Looks like another trip to Youngstown ohio for really great pizza. My niece owns a tavern in the ytown area and her pizza is better than any pizza so far in central ohio
DW
David White
Nov 18, 2025
3.0
They haven’t put up a new sign since the tornado and it looks dumpy for the area. Come on guys…be better neighbors!
SO
SGD Ortman
Nov 14, 2025
1.0
First time trying the pizza, dough is almost raw..not much flavor (mild sauce)! Undercooked pizza is what we received 17.00🍕..We through most of it away 🗑️...
We provide delivery services to locations within a 5-mile radius of our restaurant.
What are your business hours?
Our operating hours are as follows: Monday through Thursday, we are open from 6:00am to 9:00pm. On Fridays, we extend our hours until 10:00pm. Saturdays, we open at 7:00am and close at 10:00pm. Sundays, we are open from 7:00am to 9:00pm.
Do you offer catering services?
Yes, we do provide catering services for various events and occasions.
What are the opening hours of Cheshire Market?
Cheshire Market is open from 6:00 AM to 9:00 PM Monday through Thursday and Sunday, and from 6:00 AM to 10:00 PM on Friday and Saturday.
What types of food does Cheshire Market serve?
Cheshire Market offers delicious pizzas, Stromboli, hot and cold sandwiches, breakfast sandwiches, subs, wings, and a salad bar, along with lunch specials and a pizza and salad buffet.
Does Cheshire Market have dine-in and takeout options?
Yes, Cheshire Market provides both dine-in and carryout options for your convenience.
Is Cheshire Market family-friendly and wheelchair accessible?
Yes, Cheshire Market welcomes families and has wheelchair accessible entrances and restrooms, including high chairs for children.
What payment methods are accepted at Cheshire Market?
Cheshire Market accepts American Express, Cash, Check, Discover, MasterCard, and Visa credit and debit cards.
Does Cheshire Market serve alcohol?
Yes, Cheshire Market serves beer and other alcoholic beverages.
When does the kitchen close at Cheshire Market?
The kitchen closes 30 minutes before the official closing time.
Are there nearby attractions to visit before or after dining at Cheshire Market?
Yes, you can visit Alum Creek Reservoir for outdoor activities like fishing or the Alum Creek Mountain Bike Trail for biking. For a sweet treat, Sticky Fingers Ice Cream Parlor is close by.
Can customers pick up live bait while dining at Cheshire Market?
Yes, there is a live bait shop located next door, great for those fishing at the nearby lake, allowing you to get bait and food all in one stop.
What other dining options are nearby Cheshire Market?
Nearby dining options include Water's Edge Sports Grill, Water's Edge Pizza & Pub, and Tavern At The Creek, offering more variety if you're exploring the area.