The food is consistently praised for its flavor and portion sizes, with many customers highlighting specific dishes like al pastor and quesabirria tacos as favorites.
Service Issues
Numerous reviews mention slow or inattentive service, with some customers experiencing significant delays and poor treatment from staff.
Atmosphere
The restaurant has a generally positive atmosphere, though some customers noted issues with cleanliness and noise levels.
Customer Experience
Several reviews indicate a decline in customer service quality, with reports of staff being unresponsive or dismissive, impacting overall dining experiences.
Value for Money
While many customers feel the food is worth the price, some express concerns about rising costs and perceived value, particularly regarding portion sizes.
CM
Cindy Miller
Nov 16, 2025
5.0
The food was great. I tried a new 3 taco dish that was wonderful. The rest of our party enjoyed their food as well.
TH
T Tucker Hill
Nov 10, 2025
3.0
Seemed like the waiter was rushing us to order and hurry to get out even though it was a Monday and they were empty. Didn't like that feeling. The food was decent otherwise.
LH
Lori Hewitt
Nov 10, 2025
4.0
Food is very good at a fair price. Had leftovers for lunch the next day. Service was a little slow initially as there seemed to be confusion about whose table it was....a major pet peeve of mine. But the food came quickly. Restaurant was clean. Just a little loud for my taste. Pina Colada was amazing!!!
AS
Ashley Sledge
Nov 7, 2025
5.0
Today I celebrated my daughter's sweet 16 birthday at El Vaquero, and I knew Carlos, our favorite server/bartender, would make it extraordinary - and he exceeded all expectations! Despite having a party of 8, he made my daughter feel like a princess. Her Sprite came in a beautiful glass with special garnishes, and her food arrived first, wrapped in foil to ensure it was piping hot straight from the grill. When it was time for the cake I brought, Carlos coordinated everything perfectly - storing it safely, bringing it out with lit candles, and gathering his whole team to sing happy birthday. He even had cake plates, a knife, and to-go boxes ready to go. The most magical moment came when Carlos presented my daughter with a rose he crafted from foil, telling her to make a wish and place it on the right side of her bed - which she did! (Though I'm hoping she's not wishing for more Uggs 😂). Carlos always makes us feel like we're part of the El Vaquero family, and we'll definitely be back for our next celebration!
BS
Brad Shaffer
Nov 5, 2025
4.0
The first time I ate here straight from Arizona I did not like it, however after living in the area now for a few years it's comparatively very good to other local Mexican foods. The service is always friendly the restaurant has always clean and bright and not too loud either. As far as dishes go I've had many, I like the quesabirria tacos My wife enjoys the potato flautas. The kids usually get one of the kids meals either chicken fingers or a pizza or a hamburger.
Frequently Asked Questions About El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant
What are the regular operating hours for El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant?
El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant is open from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM from Monday to Thursday and Sunday, with extended hours on Friday until 10:30 PM and Saturday until 10:00 PM.
During what hours is delivery service available at El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant?
Delivery is available daily from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM Monday through Thursday and Sunday, until 10:30 PM on Friday, and until 10:00 PM on Saturday.
Does El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant offer takeout options?
Yes, takeout is offered daily from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM Monday through Thursday and Sunday, with extended hours until 10:30 PM on Friday and 10:00 PM on Saturday.
What services are available for ordering food from El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant?
Customers can choose from in-store pickup and delivery services offered by El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant.
Where is El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant located?
El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant is located at 375 Stoneridge Ln, Gahanna, OH 43230, United States.
How can I view the menu or place an order online?
You can view the menu or place an order online at https://vaquerorestaurant.com/menu.
What type of cuisine and dining options does El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant offer?
El Vaquero is a Mexican restaurant offering tacos, burritos, seafood, vegetarian options, and also functions as a family restaurant, bar, and caterer.
Are there nearby rental car services that customers can use when visiting El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant?
Yes, Budget Car Rental, Avis Car Rental, and Budget Rent A Car are nearby, useful for customers who need a rental vehicle before or after dining at El Vaquero.
What entertainment options are near El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant for visitors to enjoy?
Nearby entertainment options include Cinemark Stoneridge Plaza Movies 16 for cinema experiences and The Karaoke Lab for karaoke and events.
Are there any shops or services near El Vaquero Mexican Restaurant that visitors might find convenient?
Yes, nearby are Q2 Jewelry and Services for jewelry and fashion accessories, Synergi Hair Salon for beauty services, and HomeGoods for furniture and home items.