The Toasted Yolk Cafe

Reviews

• GE

  George Elston

  1 day ago
  3.0
  Progressively been getting worse and worse over the last 3 times going, first it was just the food, everything has too much salt lately, last time it was food and service, everything was wrong and still way too much salt, tried going today and our server proceeded to make eye contact with us about 9 times but ignored us for the ten minutes we sat, even though there were only 3 tables in the restaurant, thankfully currently enjoying my bob Evans breakfast, server at bobs had our drinks and order in within a minute of being sat
• TT

  ThatBronyGuy

  2 days ago
  1.0
  We got the Arnold Benedict and chicken and waffles for breakfast. Slow servace but was a bit busy. The Benedict was lacking flavor, English muffin wasnt toasted and wasn't exactly warm but the grits were hot. The chicken and waffles. Lacking both hot honey and jalapeno, but wasn't able to wave down my server. Waffles were over cooked and falling apart. Chicken was burnt, dry stringy. Difficult to cut and breading falling off. We were in too much of a rush to leave to bring it up with management and not planning on going back. Do not recommend at all, our server was ok. More like the Toasted Yuck!
• TC

  tammy cooper

  Apr 16, 2026
  5.0
  I just love this place!! The food is so good. If you've never been here, ask for the free donuts, you won't be disappointed.
• JL

  Jeff Loughman

  Apr 2, 2026
  4.0
  This is our 2nd visit to Toasted Yolk, Findlay, Ohio. The atmosphere is pretty modern and the seating set-up is nice. Our server was very friendly and gave us plenty of time to decide on our meals. I ordered the make your own scramble and it was delicious. The cheese grits are great and I'll definitely be ordering them again. My daughter ordered the egg, bacon and Gouda sammich and enjoyed it but thought the bacon overpowered the sandwich. We also got the Churro donuts as a free appetizer and holy smokes. The donuts come with a caramel sauce and we both said the donuts were outstanding on their own but once you are that caramel sauce out elevates them to a must have. We enjoyed our experience and will be back!
• MM

  m

  Mar 29, 2026
  1.0
  Everyone at the table ordered breakfast. Three of us ordered the Classic Arnold. The food was atrocious. Inedible in fact. The plates were eventually cleared with the food remaining, uneaten. The server was having a really bad day. We enjoyed each other’s company. But, everyone decided we will never return to the Toasted Yolk.

Frequently Asked Questions About The Toasted Yolk Cafe