Burntwood Tavern

Reviews

• AC

  A Cloud

  3 days ago
  3.0
  Steak was overcooked and tough, lobster bisque was cold and had shrimp on it , was served with dinner, veggies came cold, dessert was good but serving containers make no sense ( ice cream on warm dessert and when you try to eat it it spills out). Wasn’t great for the price.
• MS

  Mace Saenger

  3 days ago
  3.0
  Went here to splurge and treat ourselves for a date night. We were pretty disappointed. I normally like to give glowing reviews but I feel honesty is the best policy. We got the pretzel for an app, lobster bisque and chili for side soups, then the smash burger and Nashville Milanese for entrees. The pretzel was good, no complaints. The soups were remarkably small for the price--for ~$11, where most entrees are around $17-20, you'd expect something relatively substantial. These were tiny cups, even then only half full. If I had to eyeball it, the bisque was maybe 4oz assuming an 8oz bowl, the chili possibly 5 or 6. The chili was very good, but most of the volume was sour cream. The bisque was more gelatinous than it was liquid. Yes, bisque is thick by definition, but it shouldn't sit in a pile on a spoon and jiggle. It also had very little actual lobster in it (if any, it was very hard to tell what was shrimp and what wasn't); I'd be more okay with the price to volume ratio of there was perceptible lobster meat. The smash burger was very flavorless. We each tried a bite and it was just not good. Just meat, bun, and wet. The waiter was very kind and took it off the bill, which we were very grateful for. The fries were good still. The Milanese was tasty, but kind of...amateur? I feel bad describing it that way, but genuinely I could have believed it was something from the premade section at the grocery store that you heat and assemble yourself. The cutlet was well seasoned and fried, but the "herbs and greens" appeared to be chunks of iceberg lettuce slathered in a white sauce. The waiter was very nice and we made sure to tip him well in cash. I have only ever sent food back at a restaurant once in my life before this so I was so nervous, but he was so understanding and made it a total non-issue. Maybe the restaurant was having an off day, but there were too many things that just weren't good or worth what we spent that I felt compelled to leave this review.
• BF

  Brenda de La Fuente

  Feb 22, 2026
  3.0
  food was ok, service was ok a little overpriced. would not come back
• BM

  briella mcgilton

  Feb 12, 2026
  5.0
  My boyfriend and I came to celebrate for Valentine’s Day and we had the most amazing server, Josh!!! He was phenomenal. I had the shrimp carbonara which was amazing and my boyfriend had the smash burger (recommended by Josh). Everything was delicious!! We had an amazing date and I will make sure to ask for Josh next time I come in!!
• TK

  Tatum Kehres

  Feb 4, 2026
  5.0
  brooklynn was an AMAZING server, very attentive and personable. just wow, she made our experience wonderful. gave GREAT drink and food recommendations. had our glasses full the entire time. ask for her! she is fr the best , super funny too so definitely 100/10 recommend her !!

Frequently Asked Questions About Burntwood Tavern