Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• DM

  Dreanna mcneal

  5 days ago
  5.0
  Yesterday night I came to this location for pizza and a brownie. Food was perfect I’m not sure what the lady’s name in there working by herself but she is amazing not only are you working under pressure but made the food perfect with great customer service. Thank you so much for your great service!!
• IT

  Ivy Taylor

  Feb 24, 2026
  1.0
  played so bad with my doordash order.. didn’t cut the slices even and it was burnt. this happened on tuesday feb 24th around 9pm.
• OB

  Onisha Burch

  Feb 22, 2026
  1.0
  Just disgusting. Cheese is not even melted. I ordered the pizza at 1:53pm and it was delivered to my house by 2:20pm.. how? Every thingI ordered was either nasty or wrong. I normally do not complain but this is just unacceptable.
• AA

  Aaron Arney

  Feb 19, 2026
  5.0
  5/5 Stars – Exceptional Customer Service at Papa Johns on S High St! I recently ordered the new pan pizza from this location, and unfortunately, there was a mix-up with my order a few days ago—it didn't come out quite right. I reached out, and Al the manager was incredibly accommodating and professional from the very first interaction. He immediately took ownership of the issue, apologized sincerely, and credited my account fully without any hassle or questions. When I placed my next order, everything was perfect—the pizza was hot, fresh, loaded with toppings, and the crust was spot-on. Al's quick resolution turned what could have been a frustrating experience into a positive one, and it really shows the level of care this team puts into their customers. The staff here is friendly, efficient, and clearly committed to making things right. This High Street location has earned my loyalty—I'll definitely be back for more of that delicious Papa John's pizza. Highly recommend! Thank you, Al and the team—you rock!
• BB

  Brontë

  Feb 15, 2026
  5.0
  Al - the manager - is THE bomb. He was so kind and funny, my girls and I walked in on Galentines to pick up pizzas, and he was joking with us, laughing, and the food was great. They had it ready for us, no problems at all. 10/10, they came in clutch. AL YOU ROCK!