Mitchell's Steakhouse

Reviews

• AR

  Amber Rayburn

  Feb 28, 2026
  2.0
  I’m not sure what happened. A year or so ago this place was great. Last night was such a let down. It wasn’t busy at all which sort of concerned me and I wondered if the place was going downhill. The decor is definitely outdated, cracks in the walls, etc but places age. My issue was the steaks. My boyfriend and I both ordered a filet medium well. We fully understand that they may need to be butterflied to cook to this level. We weren’t not asked. His steak in the middle was rare - I’m talking juices ran very red. Mine was more on the medium side. The waitress saw our faces when we cut them open and she knew they were not right. I’m not one to send food back or complain so when she asked if we wanted a steak we already cut in half thrown back on the grill we declined. We didn’t ask for a refund or discount. The jalepeno scalloped potatoes used to be SO good! I NEVER add salt to my food after it’s been prepared but it was the only way these were flavorful. Not sure what is going but it was very disappointing.
• CS

  Connor Simmons

  Feb 15, 2026
  2.0
  Came here for the first time yesterday with my girlfriend for Valentine’s Day and it was awful, but the atmosphere is fantastic. I wanted to like this place so much. We got seated in a dark corner where they had glasses, plates and silverware stacked up ready to be put away. I asked if we could be moved to any of the other open tables that looked available so workers wouldn’t be pushing behind us to get things they needed and so we could be out in the main area, and was told we’d have to wait an additional hour to be seated there. So we take what we got, sit down (most of the tables were never occupied while we were eating). Our waitress never introduced herself or any kind of greeting. We order our food and wait for an hour before we get our food. We were never checked up on or anything in this time. I got the surf and turf and my girlfriend got the filet. Our steaks were pretty good, but my steak was maybe 3 oz. The lobster tail was crying for help with how overcooked it was, and my girlfriend’s shrimp scampi that she got with her steak came with 3 shrimp that were like chew toys. For $180 I expected a lot better overall. We won’t be returning here and I recommend you don’t waste your time either.
• NK

  Nathan Kazee

  Feb 15, 2026
  3.0
  My wife and I sort of made Mitchell's Steakhouse a Valentine's Day tradition. The first few times we were there everything was perfect. We haven't been in a few years and decided to go back and continue the tradition. Unfortunately, this may be the last time. We were seated prior to our 6:30 reservation. After we were seated, though, it became very clear that they did not schedule an appropriate amount of staff. It took a good while to see our waiter, then another good while to get bread and drinks. Our waiter had even told us they were very busy that night, which is to be expected, as Valentine's day fell on a Saturday this year, which is what made us believe they were ill prepared. We both ordered the Australian Wagyu New York Strip. We both ordered our steaks medium rare. My wife's steak came out OK, however mine was on the medium well side. The waiter offered to remake it, which they did, and even the new steak came out medium/medium rare. I decided to just eat it anyway. Both steaks were horrible. No flavor, extremely hard to chew. At this point we had been waiting on our second round of drinks for about 30 minutes. The waiter again apologized and stated that the bartender was incredibly backed up. One bartender, Valentine's day, Saturday night. The drinks were very good, it was just unfortunate that they consistently took so long to arrive to the table. On the menu, the wagyu is $79. Upon receiving our check, they had put 3 wagyu steaks on the bill, at $85 a piece. After speaking with the waiter, again, he corrected both issues and brought us the correct bill. We used to LOVE coming to Mitchell's for a nice night out, but the quality has just gone down overall. Our waiter was great, we could tell he was being overworked. The drinks were great. The rest, not so much. This experience was a 2/5 stars, but I gave a 3/5 rating due to past experiences.
• OM

  Oumou Mbodji

  Feb 15, 2026
  1.0
  I am beyond disappointed and frankly angry about my recent visit to Mitchell’s Steakhouse. What should have been an enjoyable dining experience turned into a frustrating and unacceptable mess. The service was completely incompetent. Our server was inattentive, disorganized, and clearly unprepared. Orders were forgotten, and we had to constantly remind staff about basic items including bread, which we repeatedly asked for and never received. No guest should have to beg for something that simple. To make matters worse, our meals were brought out at completely different times. Some of us were sitting there with no food while others were already halfway done eating. That is unacceptable at any restaurant, especially one that presents itself as a steakhouse with standards. The menu was extremely limited, and there were barely any drink options available. Between the poor food, the lack of coordination, and the overall disorganization, this experience did not come close to meeting even basic expectations. We left feeling frustrated, ignored, and extremely dissatisfied. This was not just a minor inconvenience it was a complete failure in service and quality. I expect this to be taken seriously.
• KM

  Khadidia Mbodji

  Feb 15, 2026
  1.0
  I am beyond disappointed with my experience at Mitchell’s Steakhouse. From start to finish, it was a complete mess. The service was absolutely horrible. Our server was incompetent and unprofessional. He forgot multiple items we ordered, didn’t bring all the food out at the same time, and somehow still managed to mess things up even though he “wrote it down.” We had to remind him THREE times to bring bread. I’m still waiting for it to this day. The food was just as bad as the service. It came out cold, lacked flavor, and was honestly terrible. For a steakhouse, that’s embarrassing. On top of that, the menu was extremely limited, and to make matters worse, they were out of several menu items AND most of the drinks. How are you out of basic drinks and staple dishes? The entire experience felt disorganized and careless. No urgency, no accountability, no effort to fix anything. It’s frustrating to spend your money somewhere expecting a good meal and decent service, only to leave feeling annoyed and disappointed. I would not recommend Mitchell’s Steakhouse to anyone. There are far better places to spend your time and money.