Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• AS

  Allias Star

  6 days ago
  2.0
  4/6/26 (late night) I watched that chick put my pizza together in literally 15 seconds and it came out looking like it was made in 15 seconds! Barely any cheese on there. Laziest looking pizza I’ve ever seen.
• MS

  Michael Starksjr

  6 days ago
  1.0
  My order always show up late the pizza be cold and they always mess my order up I wish you can set me a free pizza cuz they always mess my order up the Papa John's in Norwood if I keep dealing with them the app to give me a free pizza if they will make the do business with them
• CG

  Chad Geiser

  Apr 4, 2026
  1.0
  Papa John’s use to be good now it’s just crap. I ordered the pan pizza with pepperoni, and it was not cooked all the way through and so greasy. I will never order from the Winton road store again. Larosa’s was bad for a while but lately pizzas have been cook perfectly I guess Papa John’s hired all the rejects Larosa’s got rid of.
• AR

  Angela Ragio

  Mar 12, 2026
  5.0
  Great new pan pizza absolutely love love love it!!great job im Italian and both parents are proffesional chefs so im extremely picky on any type sauce pasta dough above all cheese is my favorite sauce very important, it past every test my new favorite pizza at papas!thank u for great service, staff on winton an Compton needs a standing applause always proffesional kind and caring keep up good work
• TT

  The Truth

  Mar 4, 2026
  1.0
  I don't know about the other locations, but the Finneytown location is terrible! The workers are nice, but the pizzas are always disappointing! They skimp on ingredients and sauce, no matter how plead with them. And if they offer a special (forget it), you will barely get anything on it. I said that I wasn't going to go back to them for awhile after my previous disappointing experiences, but they had a special, so I thought I'd give them another try.....Disappointed again! So now it's back to Domino's where I've been getting my pizzas 🍕 lately, and they're pretty good. Their ingredients aren't always end to end on the pizzas, but at least they're on there, and they don't skimp on them! It wasn't always like this with Papa Johns.....don't know what happened?