We serve up small batch, Cincinnati-style chili and fresh, hot 100% American beef burgers crafted by hand and made to order. Our chili is cooked in small batches to ensure the quality, flavor and texture are perfect, every time. And the burgers? Well, they really are from flat top grill heaven - juicy, perfectly cooked and even better when topped with our famous chili.
Overall, customers praised the fast and friendly service, with many highlighting specific staff members for their excellent service.
Food Quality
While many reviews complimented the food as delicious and fresh, there were also complaints about inconsistency in food preparation and portion sizes.
Order Accuracy
Several customers reported issues with incorrect orders and missing items, indicating a need for improvement in order accuracy.
Cleanliness
The restaurant was generally noted for being clean, although some reviews mentioned unsanitary conditions.
Pricing Concerns
Customers expressed mixed feelings about pricing, with some finding it reasonable while others considered it overpriced.
MM
Marky Mark
Oct 30, 2025
4.0
Ordered a 3 way at drive thru. Didnt check food at window, it came without cheese on it. 😭😭😭
GG
George
Sep 27, 2025
5.0
The service is always so fast here! Food is always hot and fresh and they make sure you have everything you need to go with it. Top marks for the staff 👏
TO
That OhioStateGirl
Sep 25, 2025
5.0
What a lovely time my Granny and I had today! Matt not only provided us with excellent service, but also cooked our wonderful food himself! In a world full of chaos in which great customer service is hard to come by, Our experience Today was refreshing and delightful! I also appreciate that gold star is keeping their prices affordable While other restaurants are Using the excuse of tariffs to gouge their patrons!!! Thanks Matt & The Gold Star Hartwell team!
CA
Carolyn Apel
Sep 22, 2025
5.0
We had such great service and food delivered! Love the 5-Way, a friend got the 3-Way (some people just don't love beans and onions, but that's their problem!) and we shared the cheese coneys. Yum! Perfect first rainy fall supper!
JD
Jordan Deardorff
Sep 13, 2025
1.0
Sat at the table for 15+ minutes never even greeted, I was the only person in the restaurant. Just went ahead and left to eat somewhere else.