Donatos Pizza

Reviews

• RC

  Ricardo Caldera

  Feb 18, 2026
  1.0
  long wait
• DJ

  Dan Johnson

  Feb 11, 2026
  5.0
  Staff made our youth basketball teams visit a success! Naturally the pizzas were delicious 😋 Lobby needs some attention. I'd start with a lighting upgrade. Or just make it so you can see!
• IR

  Ivan Rorick

  Feb 8, 2026
  1.0
  Placed an order for a pizza. Was given a delivery time of 8 pm. By around 8:15 it hadn't arrived. Called and asked what was going on. After some effort I got them to admit that my pizza wouldn't get here until about 9:30. I had to leave here at 9:00 so that was a no go. Was effectively told that my order wasn't a priority because I'm on The Plains and they "only have one driver." No effort was made to reach out and let me know that my order would be arriving 90 minutes late. I would have just sat there waiting for it the whole time if I hadn't finally called. I cancelled the order. Don't order from here if you live on The Plains. If they "only have one driver" you're screwed.
• TM

  Timothy Miller

  Feb 2, 2026
  5.0
  Okay, let me start off by saying a friend of mine told me Donatos Pizza in Athens was disgusting, so I took them at their word, but last night changed everything. I've had Domino's, Avalanche, Papa John's, pizza cottage and Plus One pizza and I've had nothing but problems from poor taste and skimpy toppings. So last night I decided to order from Donatos, and I was very surprised. The toppings were plentiful the crust was amazing, and the taste was outstanding. Everything was fresh, and in my opinion the best pizza in Athens. Thank you Donatos! You just picked up a repeat customer.
• CL

  Chris Ladeaux

  Jan 29, 2026
  4.0
  Good pizza but slow overworked and understaffed people.