Trattoria Aroma

4.3
490 reviews

About

Italian RestaurantRestaurant
Trattoria Aroma on Main Street in Williamsville is the best Italian restaurant to visit for homemade Italian dishes, a selection of fine wines, and catering for small events and parties. We’re proud to serve clients in Buffalo, NY; Williamsville, NY; Amherst, NY; Clarence, NY; and all of Western New York. Whether you want to enjoy authentic cuisine made with fresh ingredients, you want a warm and inviting atmosphere, or your focus is more on impeccable service, we have it all! Stop by today to see why people are raving about us.

Location

Trattoria Aroma
5229 Main Street, Williamsville, NY
14221, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.3
490 reviews
5 stars
331
4 stars
70
3 stars
24
2 stars
26
1 star
39

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Food Quality

While many customers praised the food as delicious and authentic, there were several complaints about blandness, overcooked dishes, and inconsistency in portion sizes.

Service Experience

Service received mixed reviews; some customers highlighted attentive and friendly staff, while others reported long wait times and poor management interactions.

Atmosphere

The restaurant's atmosphere was generally described as cozy and inviting, but some reviews noted a tense environment influenced by management behavior.

Value for Money

Several customers felt that the prices were high relative to the quality and portion sizes of the food, leading to dissatisfaction with the overall value.
  • MH
    Miguel Hernandez
    2 days ago
    5.0
    Me and my family absolutely loved this place! We came from Dallas the weekend the Bills played the Bengals exactly for that game because my son is a very big Bills fan and we wanted to have a nice dinner the Saturday before so we found this place and it did not disappoint. We did walk in a bit late, maybe an hour before they closed, but nonetheless the owner welcomed us in like we were family. He and his business partner attended to us for the majority of the night. The food was excellent, I got the lobster ravioli, my son got the spaghetti and meatballs and his godfather ask for a special request and with no hesitation it was made. And to end off the night the owner offered us a drink of Limoncello, it was perfect. I wanna thank them for the great hospitality and great service, hopefully we'll be back for another game and without a doubt we will be there for our Saturday night dinner!
  • JV
    Julie Volere
    Jan 3, 2026
    5.0
    Stopped in for brunch and we were delighted with the options and quality of food, and the European style charm of this restaurant. Jeanie embodied hospitality and kept the amazing coffee topped up, and the baked eggs were fire! We look forward to trying out the pizza from their brick pizza oven.
  • MA
    Michael Adelizzio
    Dec 20, 2025
    5.0
    The manager was very engaged with the clientel. The food was outstanding. We met the Chef Cortez who has inspiring dishes and the atmosphere was superb. The bartender not only made our drinks, he recommended certain wines for certain dishes. And the cost for a table of 6 was amazing. This is a place you not only should try, but frequently come back to. Thank you to all of you for a great night
  • RD
    Roselina Darling
    Dec 17, 2025
    1.0
    Would give zero stars if I could. This place was a huge disappointment. The biggest problem here starts at the top. The owners create an uncomfortable, tense environment that seeps into every part of the restaurant. Their attitude and behavior are impossible to ignore, and the way staff interacts around them makes it clear this is not a healthy or respectful place to work — which immediately ruins the dining experience. The food was mediocre at best and wildly overpriced for what you get. Nothing stood out in a good way. The atmosphere felt dated and catered almost exclusively to an older regular crowd. This restaurant presents itself as warm and family-oriented, but that couldn’t be further from the truth. It feels forced and transactional, like they’re just taking whatever they can get. For the money, there are far better options nearby. I won’t be returning.
  • SD
    Sheila D
    Dec 11, 2025
    5.0
    What an absolutely amazing dining experience we had! Everything was perfect, from beginning to end. Our party was greeted warmly and immediately seated. The menu was so appetizing weren't sure what to order. Our server was friendly and knowledgeable, eventually helping a few of us pick out our dinner. The food was unbelievable! It was hot, fresh and delicious!!! It also was visually appealing. The owner stopped by to welcome us, making us feel that our visit was appreciated. He was warm and funny. keeping everyone in a lighthearted mood We will definitely visit again very soon. Five stars!

Frequently Asked Questions About Trattoria Aroma

Does Trattoria Aroma offer catering services?

Yes, Trattoria Aroma provides catering and banquet options for events of all sizes. Our fresh Italian cuisine and professional service make any gathering memorable.

Can I purchase gift certificates at Trattoria Aroma?

Absolutely. Gift certificates are available and make the perfect present for birthdays, anniversaries, holidays, or to contribute toward a special catering order.