Giancarlo’s Sicilian Steakhouse

Reviews

• RC

  Rosco the Buf-Lo Cop Critic

  1 day ago
  5.0
  "G" Steakhouse is truly an excellent restaurant. Celebrating a birthday with friends, each of the courses had their designated pairing of wines. Out of the 5 wines, only one was just ok, the others choices were superb. Why we picked a night 🌙 that the Bills were playing, we didn't check. But if you can imagine 4 cell phones propped up at a fine dining 🍽 restaurant, all tuned into the game, yes, that's what we did. Savanna was our server and we were given a small card, with brief history about our server. Made the experience slightly more personal...
• SS

  Scotchas

  6 days ago
  5.0
  Love this place. Food and service is amazing! We had short rib and veal- both amazing! Note: if ordering veal it’s a very generous portion. Jeff served us, was great, knowledgeable and super friendly! We always look forward to coming and trying something different on the menu. Highly recommend! Make sure to make reservations.
• DK

  David Kaplan

  6 days ago
  1.0
  This was the first time I sat and had a meal at the restaurant. The meal for everyone was awful. The new pizza was a complete joke. It is robbery you are charging $19 for something that is worth about $2.00. It tasteful awful and can't believe you serve that to customers. It looked like a 10 year made the pizza in their home kitchen. The pork chop Marsala was extremely dry and lacked flavor except for the sauce. The filet was a touch warm and that is sad for $70. The server sold me on a sauce for the filet and he never brought it. We asked for Siracha for our appetizer med platter and it came out during the main meal. We asked for a bud light bottle and a side glass for the beer. He brought a glass with the beer in it, that is not how it was ordered. Total waste of over $500.
• JH

  Joe Hernandez

  Nov 6, 2025
  5.0
  Great place, amazing food( Mediterranean platter so good !!! Delmonico steak, shoet rib with polenta, truffle frites, mash and au gratin- absolutely delightful !!!), great live music / environment. Packed on a Wednesday ! Thanks Zach, absolutely great from start to finish. Superb / exceptional experience for our 8th anniversary.
• DG

  Dr.Guillermo Gomez

  Oct 26, 2025
  5.0
  Nestled on the outskirts of Buffalo, NY, Giancarlo’s Sicilian Steakhouse is a hidden gem that beautifully marries the rich traditions of Sicilian cuisine with a unique fusion style. Drawing inspiration from the diverse culinary influences of the Middle East, Greece, North Africa, France, Spain, and Rome, the restaurant offers a delightful journey through flavors that are both familiar and extraordinary. Atmosphere and Ambiance As soon as you step into Giancarlo’s, you’re enveloped in a warm atmosphere that feels like a Mediterranean escape. The rustic wooden furniture and carefully curated decor create a charming environment that sets the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. Every detail—from the non-wrinkled linens to the polished cutlery—speaks to the restaurant's commitment to quality and authenticity. Dining Experience On a recent visit with my wife and a colleague, we were fortunate to be guided by our exemplary server, Katie. Her professionalism and attention to detail immediately stood out. With a warm introduction and a card placed at our table, she ensured we felt welcomed and well taken care of throughout the evening. We indulged in a variety of dishes, each showcasing the restaurant's commitment to excellence: Cocktails: A perfect way to start the evening, expertly crafted and refreshing. - Arancini: These fried rice balls were crispy on the outside and delightfully creamy within, setting the tone for the meal. - Crab Crusted Salmon: This dish was a standout, with the crab adding a rich layer of flavor to the perfectly cooked salmon. - 17 oz Delmonico Angus Beef: A meat lover's dream! Juicy, tender, and cooked to perfection. - Charred Lasagna: This dish was a delicious twist on a classic, with layers of rich flavor that left us wanting more. - Pistachio Gelato: The perfect ending to our meal, this gelato was creamy and bursting with flavor. Accompanied by glasses of Barolo, each dish told a story of impressive culinary craftsmanship and a deep respect for Sicilian traditions. Conclusion Giancarlo’s Sicilian Steakhouse is more than just a restaurant; it’s a culinary experience that transports you to Southern Italy. With impeccable service from Katie and a menu that celebrates Sicilian fusion, we left the restaurant eager to return. It’s clear that the establishment is guarded by true brand ambassadors, dedicated to providing a memorable dining experience. I can’t wait to return and explore more of what this marvelous epicenter of Southern Italian cuisine has to offer! 🍷✨

Frequently Asked Questions About Giancarlo’s Sicilian Steakhouse