La Slice Pizzeria

Reviews

• EB

  Elias Baires

  3 days ago
  5.0
  Best pizza on Long Island must try
• MH

  Maya hazin

  6 days ago
  5.0
  Literally the best pizza ever. Especially the specialty slices. All of them are a hit. The owner is so friendly and kind and so are all of his employees.
• CR

  Cristian Ramos

  Apr 3, 2026
  5.0
  My first time visiting this place to get a slice was overwhelming due to the wide variety of options. I decided to ask the staff for recommendations on their most popular slices, and it was the best decision I’ve made. I love their pizza; it’s fantastic, with a crunchy bread that’s not too oily. I’ll continue to come back until I’ve tried everything on their menu.
• TH

  Timothy Hantzschel

  Mar 10, 2026
  5.0
  La Slice in West Islip, NY is the best! The staff is extremely dedicated, passionate and friendly. The food is high quality and 5 stars. Not just another Italian restaurant on LI. THEE ITALIAN RESTAURANT AND PIZZA RESTAURANT ON LI. Also check out their Islandia Location on the island as well if you are more out east. The people at La Slice get to know you and do not just treat you like another customer but a part of the La Slice family.
• MJ

  M J

  Mar 9, 2026
  5.0
  Honestly, wasn't expecting much from this pizza place but was VERY pleasantly surprised at how good their pies are! No soggy crust, nice and thin and best of all, their veggie pie was perfect. No big heavy pieces of vegetables, perfectly cut up and delicious. Will definitely be coming back here and recommending to others!

Frequently Asked Questions About La Slice Pizzeria