La Slice Pizzeria

Reviews

• FF

  Frank

  3 days ago
  1.0
  Purchased tortellini bordo soup 2 different days. 1 day it was $7.00 total for a large. Next time it went it was $15.00 for 2 large soups. Pricing is inconsistent and changes depending on who is working the register when you pay. Would be better going down the road for better service and consistent pricing.
• RG

  Ray Godinez

  Dec 27, 2025
  5.0
  Amazing food sauce flavor
• MW

  matt whittall

  Nov 10, 2025
  5.0
  great pizza here, nice thin crust. I got it well done and it was perfect.
• RS

  Robert Schlosser

  Nov 1, 2025
  5.0
  Been living in West Islip over 20 years consider myself a pizza snob lol. Tried all pizza places in town as well as Babylon. Have to say a lot of places been here and have to say. I ordered tonight put thin crust in my comments. Pizza was cooked to perfection. Arrived hot which was the best as its delivery usually hit or miss. So now on to the taste. Perfect everything a Pizza should be. Also ordered pepperoni pin wheel. Usually they just reheat what’s in the counter. This was 100 percent made fresh not burnt came with sauce as well. All I have to say is I will now continue to come here. I was impressed. Have been using Pizzaria Babylon and getting a delivery from them is always cold and wrong. This place honestly I liked the pizza a lot better as well as the pepperoni roll. Will trade the pastas and heroes soon. Keep up the good work and let’s keep these guys in business here to many crappy places have been in this spot. This place to me was just what we need there. Keep up the great work guys. If you haven’t ordered yet give them a try definitely worth it.
• LF

  Leonel Funes

  Oct 27, 2025
  5.0
  Food here tastes very good worth the money

Frequently Asked Questions About La Slice Pizzeria