Subway

Reviews

• KC

  Kara Coon

  Jan 10, 2026
  1.0
  Stale bread, as you can see in the picture, my sub basically crumbled, and hardly any meat. The other sub I ordered, a meatball, didn’t have the extra meatballs on it that we ordered and was so flat it looked like someone sat on it. Everytime I go in they only have one person working and they are always swamped. Unfortunately, I won’t be back.
• JB

  Janice Beyer

  Jan 10, 2026
  1.0
  This was the first time I ever had Subway food. I got the roast beef, ham and turkey sub. I was sick after I ate it. Never going back.
• DL

  Danielle Love

  Nov 1, 2025
  5.0
  Always a great visit, the nice lady in there today was nice and did everything perfect. Food is amazing, got the chicken bacon protein bowl. It was loaded with chicken and veggies, AMAZING. My daughter got the meatball sub and she loved it as well
• CS

  Campbell Sandy

  Aug 12, 2024
  1.0
  If I could give 0 stars I would in a heartbeat. Did online order and when went to pickup the worker informed they had no turkey and that they left message on phone. I never received a call so told them what to replace instead of turkey. Got home and 1 the sub roll was burnt and dry. 2 never replaced turkey with Xtra ham. Called Carthage New York subway for refund and worker stated I never told them to add more meat in place of turkey. Bull face liars. Will never go back. Last time they ran out of lettuce, bacon, and provolone cheese. Threw the one sub in trash due to being so dry and mostly lettuce. On top of it all they were subway series subs and never got the Xtra meat and cheese. Poor poor place. Need to shut it down. Plus pretzel was hard and dry. Auntie Annie you would be so disappointed to see how they are ruining your brand
• MS

  Mathew Sanchez

  May 29, 2019
  5.0
  By far the best Subway I've eaten at. Anytime I'm near Carthage I make sure to stop there.

Frequently Asked Questions About Subway