Papa Tino's Pizzeria

4.2
630 reviews
Get DirectionsCallWebsite

Business Details

716 Mill St, Watertown, NY
13601, United States
(315) 782-7272
https://papatinospizzeria.com

About

Pizza Restaurant

Details

  • DeliveryAvailable
  • TakeoutAvailable
  • Curbside pickupAvailable

Location

Papa Tino's Pizzeria
716 Mill St, Watertown, NY
13601, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.2
630 reviews
5 stars
425
4 stars
73
3 stars
41
2 stars
23
1 star
68

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Food Quality

Customers generally praised the food, especially the pizza and wings, noting them as delicious and well-prepared.

Service Issues

Many reviews highlighted consistent problems with service, including long wait times, incorrect orders, and rude staff.

Delivery Timing

Numerous customers reported issues with delivery times being significantly longer than promised, leading to frustration.

Customer Experience

While some customers had positive experiences with friendly staff, others reported unprofessional behavior and poor communication.
  • CH
    Constance Hudson
    Jan 4, 2026
    5.0
    Love the pizza!! Always delicious. The wait time was a bit too much. My pizza wasn’t ready until 30 minutes after my online order said it would be ready. I’ll be back, I’ll just call ahead to see what the wait time is.
  • KU
    Kimberly UnderwoodUnderwood
    Jan 1, 2026
    1.0
    If I could give zero stars I would. Our last 2 orders they have forgot half of it. Delivery driver Ask if we want the food or a refund. Dude we ordered for our dinner of course we want it. Call the store and they were completely rude about it. By the time we got the rest of our food the haddock was cold and soggy. I will not order from them again. They will not get a 3rd chance.
  • NL
    Nathan Larkin
    Dec 30, 2025
    1.0
    Food is never even close to on time.. Add an hour to when they say it will be done.. They are very well staffed, but unorganized and slow.. Its every single time, and its frustrating. After years of being late, I brought it up and they were smug.. Home Deli and Cams both have better service by a long shot!
  • JD
    Jared Dickinson
    Dec 23, 2025
    4.0
    My only complaint is that it takes 30 minutes to get one sub. I understand they have to deep fry the chicken, but other businesses in the area who make the same sub get it done a lot faster. However, the food/ingredients are much better than other businesses so I keep coming back.
  • ND
    Nicholas Duerson
    Dec 21, 2025
    5.0
    Hands down the better of the only 2 cauliflower crust options in Watertown, Arts Jug being the other. The sauce, crust, and cheese were absolutely perfect! Wings were also 10/10
Read more reviews on Google

Frequently Asked Questions About Papa Tino's Pizzeria

What are the regular opening hours of Papa Tino's Pizzeria?

Papa Tino's Pizzeria is open Monday to Sunday from 11:00 AM. Closing time is 9:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Sunday and 10:00 PM Wednesday through Saturday.

Does Papa Tino's Pizzeria offer delivery and in-store pickup services?

Yes, Papa Tino's Pizzeria offers both in-store pickup and delivery services.