Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

Reviews

• MR

  Mike Rich

  Mar 2, 2026
  4.0
  For a pizza place, they have a pretty decent fish fry. Would probably give it a solid 7/10. Fish had flavor, batter was fluffy and crispy but a little chewy and underseasoned imo. But for 18$ I cant complain. Would eat again.
• GC

  Gina Clark

  Jan 20, 2026
  5.0
  Doug at Salvatore’s in Walworth is absolutely fantastic! He’s always friendly, professional, and goes out of his way to make sure everything is perfect. The service is consistently great, and you can tell he really cares about customers and takes pride in his work. Experiences like this are why we keep coming back. Highly recommend asking for Doug!
• ST

  Steve Trottier

  Jan 20, 2026
  5.0
  I ordered 2 meatballs subs from here and they told me 30 min and when I went to get them they were ready and the subs were out of this world the bread just melted in your mouth. My son and I split one they were huge and the other one my son took half for lunch the following day and he said we need to get them again
• SS

  Skull

  Jan 19, 2026
  5.0
  I do a lot of traveling and have eaten in places all over the East Coast. This location of Salvatore's in Walworth is a standout. Apparently it used to be an auto garage and they've kept the decor, it's really cool inside. Very original. I actually got to watch the game while eating my lunch they have TVs ,small counter seating, plenty of tables and the place is very clean. It's been awhile since I went to Salvatore's because the old owner did not take care about taking care of this place. When I heard they have new owners, the new owners are young couple who really care about their food quality and their customers, I had to give it a try and I was not disappointed at all. I hope they are very successful. I think they will be because they care. Extensive menu items and a killer Buffalo chicken sandwich
• AC

  A Conner

  Jan 19, 2026
  5.0
  This was my first time eating at Salvatore’s Walworth and I will definitely be back. I was surprised how extensive the menu was, they have so many options beyond pizza. We had buffalo chicken sandwiches, fries, wings and pizza and everything was excellent. I also found the staff very friendly and helpful, the owners even stopped over to ask how everything was, which I really appreciated. Highly recommend!