Customers consistently praised the food for being delicious, with standout items like pancakes, frittatas, and avocado toast receiving high marks.
Service Issues
While many reviews highlighted excellent service, there were notable complaints about inattentive or rude staff, particularly during busy times.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's decor and ambiance were frequently described as cute, cozy, and inviting, contributing positively to the dining experience.
Wait Times
Several customers mentioned that the restaurant can get busy, leading to longer wait times, but many felt the food was worth the wait.
Takeout Experience
There were multiple complaints regarding incorrect takeout orders and lack of attention to detail in packaging.
EL
Erica Lieberman
Jan 3, 2026
5.0
The food here is so good! Sometimes there is a wait but its worth it!!
RA
Ray Pearson (Home Buyers Agent)
Dec 23, 2025
5.0
Always ba great meal here
JO
Jillian O
Dec 23, 2025
5.0
I really like this place.It's very cute and quaint.It was no wait. I loved all the food I got except the corned Beef hash wasn't the best. But the pancakes and the eggs and the hash browns were amazing!!! I also love their themed drinks and the mimosas were excellent.The service was excellent and I loved all the decorations.
KP
K P
Dec 19, 2025
5.0
I've been there a few times and I just went there again today. Iwanted to leave a review before I forgot. I've only had their breakfast food so I can't comment on their lunch.
I've gotten, omelets, pancakes, a frittata, potatoes, and a strawberry banana smoothie in my times there.
Everything has been DELICIOUS and affordable.
I got a frittata today and it was so huge I couldn't even finish it and took it home. The potatoes (comes with it) are so perfect. Crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. This was $15.75 I think. And I swear it's made with like 8 eggs (cheddar, sausage, bacon, and mushrooms)
I got a side of pancakes. They were amazing. And only $3 for a side of 2 pancakes!
I got a strawberry banana smoothie also really good. That was $5.75 I think.
My bf got a make your own omelet and also a side of pancakes.
The total was $43.77.
It was a lot of food. I have breakfast for tomorrow.
In reality I didn't NEED the side of pancakes but they were so delicious I'm glad I got them.
You will not be disappointed
KP
Kyle Petty
Nov 23, 2025
5.0
The food and service here is fantastic! I think I have a new favorite brunch spot 🥰
Frequently Asked Questions About Brownstones Coffee Sayville
Where is Brownstones Coffee Sayville located?
Brownstones Coffee Sayville is located at 229 West Main Street, Sayville, NY 11782, USA.
What are the operating hours of Brownstones Coffee Sayville?
Brownstones Coffee Sayville is open Monday through Sunday from 7:30 AM to 3:00 PM, with extended hours until 3:30 PM on Friday and Saturday.
What type of business is Brownstones Coffee Sayville?
Brownstones Coffee Sayville is a coffee shop.
How can I contact Brownstones Coffee Sayville by phone?
You can contact Brownstones Coffee Sayville at the alternate phone number +1 631-567-5376.
Does Brownstones Coffee Sayville have an official website?
Yes, the official website for Brownstones Coffee Sayville is https://www.brownstonescoffee.com.
Are there any dining options near Brownstones Coffee Sayville?
Yes, nearby dining options include Sea Crest Diner and Spear Fish Long Island, which is a seafood restaurant.
Can I visit other shops or services near Brownstones Coffee Sayville?
Yes, nearby places include Sayville Custom Mirrors for glass services, Island Pet Organic for pet grooming and supplies, and Rambling Rose Florist for flowers and gifts.
Are there any wellness or fitness centers near Brownstones Coffee Sayville?
What are some entertainment or recreational spots near Brownstones Coffee Sayville?
Nearby recreational spots include Studio Art for kids' parties and amusement, Kioto Brazilian Jiu Jitsu Sayville, and Shabby Tabby Cat Cafe for a unique cafe experience.
Are there any financial or professional services near Brownstones Coffee Sayville?
Yes, nearby financial services include Edward Jones financial advisors Scot A Krempa and Thomas W Lawler as well as B. FREDERICK CO. CPA's accounting firm.