Pizza RestaurantTake Out RestaurantRestaurant Delivery ServiceChicken Wings RestaurantSalvatore's Old-Fashioned Pizzeria
Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria is a beloved multi-location pizzeria headquartered in Rochester, NY since 1978! We serve up delicious pizzas that are crafted with the finest ingredients. Our diverse menu includes classic and gourmet pizzas, mouth-watering wings, subs, salads, pasta dishes, and more. Whether you're dining in, taking out, or enjoying our efficient delivery service, you'll experience the same high quality and exceptional taste that has made us a local favorite. Catering services are also available for events of any size. Visit one of our convenient locations to taste Rochester's Favorite Pizza!
Customers frequently reported long wait times, incorrect orders, and poor customer service experiences.
Food Quality
While many praised the food, there were numerous complaints about inconsistent quality, including burnt or undercooked items.
Staff Attitude
Several reviews highlighted rude or inattentive staff, impacting the overall dining experience.
Positive Experiences
Despite the issues, many customers enjoyed the food and appreciated friendly staff at certain locations.
KW
kendall williams
3 days ago
1.0
Paid 33 dollars for two steak subs with no steak and stale bread every time I go here I immediately remember why I don’t come here absolutely terrible, safe to say Salvatore’s glory days are well behind them.
TL
Trice L
3 days ago
1.0
We are a family that does not eat pork for religious reasons and the person who took our order forgot that we requested BEEF pepperoni and not PORK Pepperoni. When we received our order we requested a new order with BEEF pepperoni. Instead of the manager taking accountability for their mistake, he blamed us for not being clear on our order and told us not to do it again. Mind you we are long time customers and have a long history of ordering non pork products (especially beef pepperoni pizza). We asked for beef pepperoni and asked the person to repeat the order back to us as we always do. I’m seriously considering never ordering here again because this is the second time and now I’ll have to spend my night asking my god for forgiveness for eating pork smh.
SN
silver ninja
Dec 11, 2025
2.0
Usually have great food and great service , seems like both the food and the service have been going down hill lately, with wait times and deliverys taking a lot longer than any other places that I order from in the same area, it's hard to give this store my business, I'd really like to see this store bounce back and be a great location to order from again.
AK
Ashley Klinkbeil
Dec 7, 2025
5.0
Went to the highest rating Salvatore’s near us while visiting Rochester, all the workers were absolutely amazing and even loved getting to see my daughter, when she spilled milk they were very nice and assured us it was alright and we immediately started cleaning it up. I can’t express how amazingly nice the staff was especially after a bills game! And not to mention the food was absolutely delicious.
LH
Lyshawn Henry-McHugh
Nov 7, 2025
2.0
Absolutely disgusting! Their website says delivery takes 25 mins to 1 hour. It was past an hour for delivery....I called ....as i needed the pizza for a scheduled time....the manager Brittany hang up me. Very rude. Would never recommend