Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• BC

  Becky Corcimiglia

  Jan 23, 2026
  1.0
  Awful. Last time it tasted like salted Ritz Cracker, sodium, salty fast food McD’s food. My husband wanted to surprise me with a pineapple & ham (30th Anniversary…don’t judge!). No legit Italian pizzeria does this so he ordered fast food Papa John’s. He got out of his 12 hr work shift to a snow dark snow storm and called to order his pizza. He spoke to a guy who took the order of plain cheese and a ham/pineapple. He drove through a snowstorm to Papa John’s on West Ridge Road in Greece. Once there he was told his order was dropped. He asked if he could just place an order then? Trying to be courteous and still end up with fast food dinner mind you. He was told “NO, WE’RE TOO BUSY.” He waited 5-10 min for someone to come back and help him but was rebuffed that you were all TOO BUSY to help a dude just standing there waiting for some crumb of a dinner. He left. Called Salvatore’s on W. Ridge Rd and Long Pond and long story short, had delicious, hot, crusty, cheesy, saucy pizza and spicy fat wings within minutes. Without attitude and arrogance and puffed out chested workers. Thank you, Salvatore’s. Next time we want pizza, we’ll stick to Italian. Rochester has one in most towns. Skip fast food ‘pizza’ and go either really cheap Dominos/Little Caesars or actually enjoy your meal and do Salvatore’s.
• YN

  Your Name

  Jan 19, 2026
  1.0
  Served me raw pizza. Waited over an hour and it was RAW. I contacted the health department. This is disgusting.
• DF

  David Farchione

  Jan 19, 2026
  1.0
  Slowest Papa John’s I’ve ever experienced.
• TM

  Tricia Monigle

  Jan 6, 2026
  5.0
  They have great people who work there and the food is consistently hot and tasty!!
• AJ

  Autumn Jean

  Dec 19, 2025
  3.0
  1st time trying Papa John's and it's definitely not for me. They put the cheese on top of the toppings so you can't even take anything off if you want. I don't like the taste, the stuffed crust was good. I also don't understand why there menus don't have prices on them. How is anyone supposed to know what to order if there are no prices on the paper menus ?

Frequently Asked Questions About Papa Johns Pizza