Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• CC

  Chris Colon

  Feb 27, 2026
  2.0
  I was very happy when I noticed papa johns came back to town after they all abruptly closed years ago, they were mine and my sons favorite of the chain pizza shops. I ordered my usual order tonight. I show up to pick up my order, the front of the store is still caved in from a accident that happened months ago, the door cant even properly close from being severely bent. My pizzas barely had any toppings on them, there was an absurd amount of cheese on them, and the "buffalo wings" were the tiniest wings I have ever seen in my life, there is literally more bone than meat on them. The pizza did taste good, and was fresh and hot when I picked it up.
• BM

  Bill maty

  Feb 10, 2026
  1.0
  The food was horrible like always. Very mediocre Pizza I've had better frozen pizza.They should have stayed out of Rochester coming back did not improve the food seen around here
• AG

  A G

  Feb 9, 2026
  4.0
  Did an overall good job. Nice employees when I picked up my food, everything was ready and made well. Would come back!
• ES

  Ether Shakur

  Feb 6, 2026
  1.0
  Pizza tasted old and undercooked I wasn't impressed at all I'm telling corporate I would like my money back expeditiously Im never ordering from them again
• RP

  Reyita Perez

  Jan 28, 2026
  1.0
  I placed an order for a large pizza and 16 wings and waited over two hours just to get a status update. When I called, they apologized and admitted the order had not been entered into the system correctly. I placed the order again, but when it arrived, the pizza did not have pepperoni or the correct toppings, and the wings were BBQ instead of buffalo and garlic parmesan as requested. I called back to report the incorrect order, but the employee I spoke with became argumentative and refused to take responsibility for the mistake. He ended up hanging up on me mid-conversation. To make matters worse, the pizza was left outside at the front of the house on top of snow without notifying us. This was extremely poor service from start to finish. I would not recommend this pizza place to anyone.

Frequently Asked Questions About Papa Johns Pizza