Business Details
About
American RestaurantBarBar & Grill
At Forest Hill Restaurant in Rochester, we're known for our generous portions, small town charm and one of the friendliest staffs in the area. Don't be surprised to see the owner during your visit, as he's usually there to greet our guests and say hello.
Whether it's dinner or drinks after a day on the water, or a quick bite to eat with your family or friends, Forest Hill Restaurant offers a diverse dinner menu to accommodate tastes from simple to sophisticated.
We invite you to stop in one evening and discover why Forest Hill Restaurant has remained a favorite among locals and visitors since 1977, and we look forward to showing you why we're one of Rochester's best kept casual dining secrets!
Details
- Dine-inAvailable
- DeliveryNot available
- TakeoutAvailable
- Accepts reservationsAvailable
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.6
269 reviews
5 stars
208
4 stars
37
3 stars
9
2 stars
6
1 star
9
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Food Quality
Customers praised the food for being delicious and well-prepared, with many highlighting specific dishes like the fish fry and seafood platter.
Service Issues
Several reviews mentioned poor service experiences, including slow service, unprofessional behavior from staff, and issues with seating and order accuracy.
Atmosphere
The restaurant has a cozy, homey atmosphere, but many found it too loud and cramped, making conversation difficult.
Owner Interaction
Feedback on the owner was mixed; while some appreciated his presence and engagement, others reported rude interactions that negatively impacted their experience.
Value for Money
Many customers felt the portions were generous and reasonably priced, contributing to a positive dining experience.
- CCCarl Hurwitch (Chuck)Oct 26, 20255.0Friendly neighborhood restaurant with exceptional food and service
- KTkaren tubioloOct 25, 20252.0Only there for a family get together. The fault of the food was not because of the waitress, she was very nice.
- NFNancy FellaOct 23, 20251.0If you are looking for mediocre tasteless food and a noisy atmosphere this is the place for you. We arrived at 6:25 for a 6:30 reservation. We were told to wait. The table was ready but we were not seated. We got drinks at the bar. We were finally seated at 7:05 pm. Waiting for anyone to acknowledge us, we were gathering cash to the bar to get another round of drinks. The host offered to get them for us. Much later, orders were taken. There was an extremely loud party so that we weren’t able to have a conversation at our table. It was a stressful disappointing experience.
- JKjohn krystanSep 29, 20251.0This place is for drunk local people only. Food was absolutely dreadful, placed smelled like fish and they dont even serve coffee anymore. They said it's to expensive to buy when no one drinks it after dinner. Outside the of the restaurant hasn't been cleaned in years. Old rotten deck with 2 guys out there drinking, smoking and spitting. Such a shame.
- BBBarbaraSep 1, 20252.0I used to work at the restaurant many years ago so a friend stopped in a few weeks ago very disappointed that they don't do vet discounts manager and waitress were very rude
Frequently Asked Questions About Forest Hill Restaurant
Where is Forest Hill Restaurant located?
Forest Hill Restaurant is located at 41 E Manitou Road, Rochester, NY 14612, US.
What kind of attire is appropriate at Forest Hill Restaurant?
The attire at Forest Hill Restaurant is casual.
What are the operating hours of Forest Hill Restaurant?
Forest Hill Restaurant is open Wednesday through Saturday from 5:00 PM to 8:00 PM and closed on Monday, Tuesday, and Sunday.
What type of cuisine and dining experience does Forest Hill Restaurant offer?
Forest Hill Restaurant offers American cuisine with generous portions, a friendly atmosphere, and a diverse dinner menu suitable for simple to sophisticated tastes.
Does Forest Hill Restaurant offer bar services and cocktails?
Yes, Forest Hill Restaurant has an onsite bar and serves cocktails, wine, beer, and other alcoholic beverages.
Can I order take-out or catering from Forest Hill Restaurant?
Yes, Forest Hill Restaurant offers dine-in, take-out food, and on-site catering services.
Does Forest Hill Restaurant offer a children's menu and family-friendly environment?
Yes, the restaurant welcomes children and has a children's menu along with high chairs available.
What are some nearby places of interest around Forest Hill Restaurant?
Nearby places include Moon Beach, Westpoint Marina at Braddock Bay, and Braddock Bay State Park, offering options for beach activities, boating, and outdoor enjoyment before or after dining.
How can visitors combine a visit to Forest Hill Restaurant with boating or fishing activities?
Visitors can enjoy dining at Forest Hill Restaurant before or after visiting Westpoint Marina at Braddock Bay for boat rentals and services or joining a fishing charter with Rochester Sport Fishing nearby.
Are there outdoor recreational activities near Forest Hill Restaurant for families or groups?
Yes, nearby options include Braddock Bay State Park, Cranberry Pond park, and Braddock Bay Fish and Wildlife Management Area, ideal for outdoor sports and nature exploration.