Italiano Pizza & Food Co.

Reviews

• BG

  BC Guy

  Jan 29, 2026
  5.0
  Everyone has their favourite pizza shop. A few years ago I lived on S.Ocean, and Italiano’s on Main was our place for food. A 25 minute walk. I faced snow, sleet, rain, or worse, but always worth it. Am back here now and again, it’s still and always the best, even better than I remembered! Great food and wonderful staff/service. Get the chicken-ranch slices, which are crunchy-&-chewy all-at-once, and line up for PinWheels-on-Tuesdays!
• DT

  Dean Theodore

  Jan 1, 2026
  5.0
  Sat down for a half pepperoni pie earlier. Service was warm and efficient, the pizza arrived in 10 to 12 minutes. There's nothing like a hot pizza and this was very well prepared. Solid base, crispy crust, cheese was stretchy and just the right amount of sauce. Very much to our liking!
• MM

  Matthew Medina

  Dec 12, 2025
  5.0
  This place is in my weekly company meal expense rotation.
• KK

  K K

  Dec 8, 2025
  5.0
  Located close or next to the Patchogue Theater. The pizza was seriously good here. Old fashioned margarita and pepperoni slices were delicious. Margarita had a subtle flavor with delicate sauce with just a hint of garlic rather than chunky sauces laden with garlic at other spots. The crust was a little thicker but didn't detract from the taste for the margarita. Pepperoni slice crust was normal thickness crust. One of the better margaritas if not the best I've found in mid-Suffolk so far. There is a good amount of self seating inside. We were there before a showtime at the theater. It got crowded. We got a table before seating became scarce. There were two rude customers hogging two separate booths that seat at least 4-6 people each to no fault of the restaurant instead of occupying tables for two that wouldn't move despite the crowd. The service was friendly and prompt. Had to wait a few minutes for the order and one of their team members brought it to our table when it was ready.
• TR

  Theresa R Rosavitch

  Dec 4, 2025
  5.0
  Yhe most important thing happened. The pizza was incredibly delicious!