Many customers praised the pizza and Italian dishes for their freshness and flavor, with specific mentions of the garlic knots, calamari pizza, and chicken parm.
Service
The staff received positive feedback for being friendly and accommodating, although some reviews noted issues with service during busy times.
Cleanliness
Several reviews highlighted cleanliness issues, including dirty tables and the presence of pests, which negatively impacted the dining experience.
Consistency
While many customers reported consistent quality over the years, some recent reviews indicated a decline in food quality and service, leading to disappointment among long-time patrons.
Pricing
Customers expressed mixed feelings about pricing, with some finding it reasonable for the quality, while others felt it was overpriced for the food received.
CM
Chuck Murphy
Oct 5, 2025
5.0
Thank you Ryan for a great pizza experience
SS
Supercat
Oct 4, 2025
5.0
Friendly staff, peak food, W aux. The calamari is peak everyone should try it. 🐐
RP
Railfanning Productions
Oct 2, 2025
5.0
They have great stuff
ST
Sara Tener
Sep 10, 2025
5.0
This is our go-to spot for pizza in Patchogue. The garlic knots, fazzanis (parmigiana, roni-pepper and san gennaro), mozzarella sticks, fresh fried mozzarella, rice balls and new york style pizza (plain, extra cheese, breaded chicken, grilled chicken, pepperoni, meatball, and olive) are always great. Very good quality food, and they have a reward system on their website were you can earn points for free food, which is nice. They also occasionally offer sale specials for certain occassions (most recent was a back-to-school one). Fyi, we always get delivery, which is consistently quoted at 40 minutes, but sometimes it arrives quicker.
RG
Ron Graziano
Aug 9, 2025
5.0
Got a regular and a Sicilian Margherita. . Had it delivered and was kept aware of every step. The flavor was on point. Everything was fresh and hot. This pizza is a step above in a land of pizzerias! Thank you!
Frequently Asked Questions About Italiano Pizza & Food Co.
What are the regular business hours of Italiano Pizza & Food Co.?
Italiano Pizza & Food Co. is open Monday to Thursday from 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM, Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM, and Sunday from 12:00 PM to 8:00 PM.
Does Italiano Pizza & Food Co. offer delivery service?
Yes, Italiano Pizza & Food Co. offers delivery services during their delivery hours.
Can I pick up my order in-store at Italiano Pizza & Food Co.?
Yes, in-store pickup is available as one of the pickup and delivery services provided.
What are the takeout hours at Italiano Pizza & Food Co.?
Takeout is available Monday to Thursday from 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM, Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM, and Sunday from 12:00 PM to 8:00 PM.
Where is Italiano Pizza & Food Co. located?
Italiano Pizza & Food Co. is located at 75 E Main St, Patchogue, NY 11772, United States.
What types of cuisine does Italiano Pizza & Food Co. serve?
Italiano Pizza & Food Co. serves Italian cuisine including pizza, pasta, sandwiches, salads, and also provides vegetarian options.
Where can I find Italiano Pizza & Food Co.'s menu online?
You can view the menu online at https://italianopizzaandfood.com/menu.
What is the price range at Italiano Pizza & Food Co.?
The price range at Italiano Pizza & Food Co. is categorized as moderate (TWO).
Are there any notable places near Italiano Pizza & Food Co. for customers to visit?
Yes, nearby places include The Loading Dock (cinema and bar), Patchogue Theatre for the Performing Arts (theatre and music venue), and Mystic Flavors Inc. (ice cream shop) which customers might enjoy before or after their meal.
If I am visiting nearby Delfiore Pizza & Food, how can I get to Italiano Pizza & Food Co.?
Italiano Pizza & Food Co. is located nearby Delfiore Pizza & Food in Patchogue, NY, making it convenient to visit both. You can walk or drive to 75 E Main St for the Italiano Pizza & Food Co. experience.