Heintzelman's BBQ Pit

Reviews

• TF

  Tina Fry

  Feb 14, 2026
  5.0
  I order doordash from here a lot and its always tasty. My husband and I decided to go in and order take out for valentines day and see what their specials were. I got the prime rib with a snow crab add on. BEST PRIME RIB I've EVER had. Not kidding. That smoky, flavorful crust was to die for. The Mac and cheese is actual southern style. Dry and crumbly like I like it. Also the house bbq blue cheese with their homemade cornbread croutons is out of this world. The owner took our to go order and she was so sweet. You can tell she takes pride in her establishment and she has right to. It was fantastic. Definitely going back and dining in soon!
• DJ

  Dominique Johnson

  Jan 29, 2026
  5.0
  This is what a real restaurant is, family friendly atmosphere, fresh food & the best staff
• CK

  Constance Kessler

  Jan 17, 2026
  3.0
  Three strikes, you're out. We've given numerous chances, always thinking we came on an 'off' day. Today was the final nail. Brisket is consistently gray and dry. I didn't even get the brisket I ordered. The waitress was cheerful and did her job well. She did remove the additional charge for my missing brisket, and Dawn visited the table and said my husband's dinner would be refunded- he tried a slice of brisket and ate his sides. Today was our very last visit. I had no doubt Dawn would be right on here, slamming a poor review. It happens every single time someone leaves one. It's amazing how many people you've encouraged not to come back. SERIOUSLY?!?! Where's Gordon Ramsay, when you need him? 🤦🙄 The customers are all wrong, not your food!
• PF

  Peter Fountain

  Jan 7, 2026
  5.0
  Great food, friendly servers, owner walked around chatting with people. Great vibe, definitely headed back.
• AA

  Annie

  Dec 20, 2025
  5.0
  Food was excellent, prices were very reasonable, and the service was outstanding.