Business Details
About
BakeryCafeCupcake ShopCatererWedding Bakery
La Roma Pastry Shop provides authentic Italian pastries, Rainbow Cheesecake, cookies, baked goods, pies, and catering services to Oakdale, NY, and surrounding areas.
Details
- Dine-inAvailable
- DeliveryAvailable
- TakeoutAvailable
- Drive-throughNot available
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.5
341 reviews
5 stars
274
4 stars
29
3 stars
10
2 stars
6
1 star
22
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Quality of Pastries
Many customers praised the freshness and quality of the pastries, particularly the cannolis and rainbow cookies.
Customer Service
Feedback on customer service was mixed; while some praised the friendly staff, others reported poor service and dismissive attitudes.
Inconsistency
Several reviews noted inconsistencies in product quality, with some items being stale or not meeting expectations.
Atmosphere
The bakery is frequently described as clean and inviting, contributing to a pleasant customer experience.
Pricing
Customers mentioned that while the prices are on the higher side, many felt the quality justified the cost.
- EEEvee5 days ago1.0Cute little spot. I was helped by a woman there and honestly felt rushed considering there was no one in the store at the time. Tried the carrot cake, strawberry cake and cannoli. They were good flavor wise but I did end up finding a hair inside the cream of the carrot cake. Im not sure if she’s the owner/baker but she seemed bothered that I brought it to her attention, rolled her eyes and said “I don’t know what happened there.” I get things happen but the way she spoke made my decision easier. She did offer another piece of cake but I was honestly grossed out at that point and declined. Won’t be going back.
- GMGeri Matzner5 days ago5.0Friendly service and a great place to enjoy their delicious cakes and coffees. I bought a rainbow cookie cheesecake for a party that was excellent. I also had a chocolate chip scone and a latte that were both great.
- KSKeith S5 days ago5.0Absolutely fantastic traditional Italian bakery with incredible pastries.
- ELErica LiebermanJan 3, 20265.0So so good!! We love everything but kiddo love the tiramisu, I love the strawberry shortcake and my husband love the napoleon ♡♡ you basically can't go wrong ♡♡
- JPJames PollinaDec 20, 20252.0Stopped there to get Savoiardi cookies. Asked if they were soft and was told yes. Bought 14 to bring to party today and two to try. They were neither soft nor fresh. This may be an exception since all the other usual pastries looked good. Will toss these and try a different place. Wasted 26 bucks but embarrassed to bring these.
Frequently Asked Questions About La Roma Pastry Shop
Do you have any Rainbow Cookie Cheesecakes Available?
Yes, we make them fresh daily!
Where are you located?
We are located inside the Lidl Shopping Center.
What time do you close?
Monday through Thursday we close at 7pm. On Friday's and Saturday's, we close at 9pm. On Sunday's we close at 7pm.
Can I place custom cake or pastry orders for special occasions, and much lead time is required?
We require 24 hours' notice for custom cake and pastry orders.
Do you offer delivery services or online ordering for your bakery products?
Yes, we offer Doordash and Uber Eats for delivery services.
Do you have Rainbow Cookie Cheesecakes available at La Roma Pastry Shop?
Yes, La Roma Pastry Shop makes Rainbow Cookie Cheesecakes fresh daily.
Where is La Roma Pastry Shop located?
La Roma Pastry Shop is located inside the Lidl Shopping Center at 4510 Sunrise Highway, Oakdale, NY 11769.
What are the opening and closing hours of La Roma Pastry Shop?
La Roma Pastry Shop is open from 7 AM to 6 PM on Monday and Sunday, 7 AM to 8 PM from Tuesday to Thursday, and 7 AM to 9 PM on Friday and Saturday.
Can I place custom cake or pastry orders for special occasions at La Roma Pastry Shop?
Yes, custom cake and pastry orders require 24 hours' notice at La Roma Pastry Shop.
Does La Roma Pastry Shop offer delivery services or online ordering?
Yes, La Roma Pastry Shop offers delivery services through Doordash and Uber Eats.
What payment options are accepted at La Roma Pastry Shop?
La Roma Pastry Shop accepts American Express, Apple Pay, Cash, Discover, Mastercard, and Visa.
Is La Roma Pastry Shop wheelchair accessible?
Yes, La Roma Pastry Shop has wheelchair accessible entrance, parking, seating, and restrooms.
Which nearby places can I visit before or after going to La Roma Pastry Shop?
Nearby places include Mathnasium of Sayville for tutoring, Bellissimo Salon for beauty services, and JJ Dynasty for Chinese and Japanese cuisine, which may complement your visit to La Roma Pastry Shop.
Can I find convenient stores near La Roma Pastry Shop?
Yes, Walgreens and 7-Eleven convenience stores are close to La Roma Pastry Shop for quick shopping needs.
Are there other food options near La Roma Pastry Shop?
Yes, nearby food options include Bella Bambina's Pizza, Pizzaiolo Gourmet Eatery, Haio Sushi & Asian Fusion, and McDonald's, offering a variety of cuisines to enjoy.