Jimmy John's

Reviews

• TD

  Treena Dixon

  Feb 10, 2026
  1.0
  I’m honestly disgusted with this experience. I bought two sandwiches on Friday, 2/6, and after eating them, both of us got violently sick. Not just a little stomach upset — we were down the entire weekend. We don’t have food allergies, and nothing else caused this. The only thing we had in common were these sandwiches, and they completely wrecked us. It’s unacceptable to pay for food and end up sick for days. Whatever is going on with the food handling at this location needs to be addressed immediately, because this should never happen. I won’t be back, and I wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone after what we went through.
• MP

  Mars Plex

  Sep 18, 2025
  1.0
  Imagine attempting to order food and you can't. And the poor employee who simultaneously is extremely rude to everyone is rushing around between Dunkin donuts in this place. Then upon further inspection you notice the hero bread itself is about the size of a breadstick from the Olive garden and they're going to try to charge you $21 for one single sandwich. Not feeling it. Don't even bother coming here. Just go to Subway or an actual deli. I predict this place will be gone in a matter of months.
• AB

  Ali B

  Aug 11, 2025
  4.0
  This location is housed along with a Dunkin, as has been mentioned in other reviews. However, it seems to be chronically understaffed. Today I went in to pick up an online order, and there was only one person working in the entire place! She had a great attitude and was doing a solid job; my order came out exactly as I placed it which was impressive considering the 7+ customers waiting. I personally watched two people leave because of the wait. The quality of the food was fine and what I expect from Jimmy John’s. I really hope the management reads this and improves their staffing - and please hire more people like Favor! She was a rock star in the circumstances.
• ML

  Mathew frias gacha life

  Jan 9, 2025
  5.0
  Best location in Long Island !!! Perfect sandwich and fresh bread !!! Thanks Jimmy Jhon’s Baldwin . clean and nice location shared with Dunkin !!