Numerous customers reported slow service, incorrect orders, and unprofessional staff behavior, leading to a frustrating dining experience.
Food Quality
Many reviews highlighted problems with food quality, including cold, dry, or improperly prepared items, which contributed to customer dissatisfaction.
Atmosphere and Cleanliness
Several customers noted issues with cleanliness, including dirty menus and bathrooms, as well as a generally uninviting atmosphere.
Management Concerns
Feedback indicated poor management practices, including inadequate staffing and failure to address customer complaints effectively.
Mixed Experiences
While some customers enjoyed their visits and praised specific staff members, the overall sentiment leaned towards disappointment due to recurring issues.
MM
MrZippo
6 days ago
4.0
Food was decent. Prices are a little high for some wings and a beer.
PJ
Pat Johonses
Nov 8, 2025
5.0
A few days ago ago, I went to Buffalo wild wings, and I could not get the thought out of my mind. Honestly, I’ve never been treated with such respect at a buffalo wild wings before, but I have to say with this specific dining experience I was blown away. I had the server, Anthony, and he treated us with such respect. He checked in on us every few minutes just to make sure that we were doing all right, brought the appetizers at such a fast fashion that I don’t know how it was possible that the food was ready in time and with Anthony himself, he cracked jokes, he talk to you like you were an actual person. He communicated with you and let you know by his attitude with his guests that he’s not just there for the money, but he’s there to make friends and family along the way. the atmosphere around the restaurant was booming. I had no issues and I’m honestly at a loss for words. thank you Anthony for the amazing service and I hope to come back to be served by you again.
MC
Mia Colman
Nov 3, 2025
3.0
Idk if the server was new or overwhelmed but, he was NOT on point with my order. Wrong flavors, wrong side dishes, kept forgetting napkins!!! My basket said "Mango Habanero" but the wings were brown sugar bbq, when I sent them back, the cook just put mango habanero on top of the brown sugar sauce 🥺. Didn't realize it til I got home!!! The worst $70 (for 2 people) that I've ever spent!!!!
ME
Mike Eilers
Oct 24, 2025
1.0
I asked for the air conditioning to be turned off it’s way too cold in here the management is terrible he told me it will shut off by its self and it’s been on the whole time that’s a lie they can turn it off it’s October the air conditioning should not be on they are freezing out the customers the need new manager
AC
Alex Conte
Oct 11, 2025
1.0
Kids working here don't care. Food is not Edible. Came in for new promo to give it a second shot. I was impressed at that price point still not worth it. I wouldn't come back if it was free.
Frequently Asked Questions About Buffalo Wild Wings
What type of food does Buffalo Wild Wings in North Babylon specialize in?
Buffalo Wild Wings in North Babylon specializes in award-winning Buffalo-style chicken wings offered in 26 different sauces and seasonings.
What are the operating hours of Buffalo Wild Wings on weekends?
Buffalo Wild Wings is open from 11:00 AM to 1:00 AM on both Friday and Saturday.
Where is Buffalo Wild Wings located in North Babylon, NY?
Buffalo Wild Wings is located at 1112 Deer Park Avenue, North Babylon, NY 11703, USA.
Can I find Buffalo Wild Wings on social media?
Yes, Buffalo Wild Wings in North Babylon has a Facebook page at https://www.facebook.com/232199736892497.
What categories of dining does Buffalo Wild Wings in North Babylon offer?
It operates as a chicken wings restaurant, sports bar, restaurant, and takeout restaurant.
What is the phone number to contact Buffalo Wild Wings in North Babylon?
You can contact Buffalo Wild Wings at +1 631-685-7522.
Are there nearby restaurants to Buffalo Wild Wings that offer different cuisines?
Yes, nearby restaurants include Hibachi Grill & Supreme Buffet (Asian cuisine), China Buffet City (Chinese cuisine), and Quac Time Mexican Grill (Mexican cuisine).
Is there a nearby place to get a quick breakfast or brunch near Buffalo Wild Wings?
Denny's, a popular breakfast and brunch diner, is located close to Buffalo Wild Wings in North Babylon.
Where can customers access WiFi close to Buffalo Wild Wings?
Customers can access WiFi at the nearby Optimum WiFi Hotspot just around the area.
What other services are available near Buffalo Wild Wings for personal or healthcare needs?
Nearby services include PM Pediatrics for pediatric care, Stand-Up MRI of Deer Park for radiology services, and various insurance agencies such as Allstate Personal Financial Representative and Paul J Dellauniversita: Allstate Insurance.