Sammy's Pizzeria

3.8
1087 reviews
Get DirectionsCallWebsite

Business Details

1400 Hyde Park Blvd, Niagara Falls, NY
14305, United States
(716) 297-8442
https://sammyspizzeria.co/

About

RestaurantRestaurant Delivery Service
We are proud to be family owned and operated for 3 generations and over 60 years in business. Sammy Musolino was the originator of the "1/2 Tray" of Pizza which has become a staple to our community.

Location

Sammy's Pizzeria
1400 Hyde Park Blvd, Niagara Falls, NY
14305, United States

Reviews

3.8
1,087 reviews
5 stars
583
4 stars
180
3 stars
74
2 stars
47
1 star
203

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Food Quality

Many customers reported issues with burnt pizza and poorly prepared food, including overcooked wings and incorrect orders.

Customer Service

Mixed reviews on service; some praised friendly staff while others experienced rude interactions and poor handling of complaints.

Delivery Issues

Numerous complaints about long wait times for delivery and incorrect or cold food upon arrival.

Atmosphere

The restaurant's atmosphere has been described as lacking cleanliness and maintenance, with some noting a decline since the pandemic.

Consistency

While some customers enjoyed their meals and praised the food, many expressed frustration over inconsistent quality and service.
  • KW
    Kelsey Wrobel
    Nov 29, 2025
    4.0
    Ordered a full tray at 9pm on a saturday, food came fresh and hot in less than an hour. Delivery drivers have always been nice
  • AL
    Angela Lasut
    Nov 19, 2025
    5.0
    Sam usual girl who answers the phone took my order spite the came and gone new girl that didn’t give me my 2 L with my order one night at pick up at closing time do not leave a note that it was not received. Despite the lack of proof. A new girl did not leave. I am a regular that calls all the time and Sam so kindly Insisted on paying for the 2 L now, not about the 2 L or the money, but on mere principal. It was not her responsibility or job to cover this matter but she yet chose to go that extra mile just for customer satisfaction
  • JK
    J Karcz
    Nov 18, 2025
    3.0
    The atmosphere and the service are not what they used to be. After Covid, it looks really dank in there. But the food is great as always
  • BL
    Bryce Lapine
    Nov 17, 2025
    1.0
    Took over 2 hours to get my delivery,pizza was overdone to the point I could barely eat it,the fried pickles were cold as ice and the wings were hot but were soaking in franks and not crispy at all ,wish I would have ordered from some other spot,the delivery driver was cool but that was seriously the worst pizza I've ever had i should have sent it back but I had just drove 8 hours and just wanted some good wings and pizza but this place is not it 1/10(only getting a 1 because of how nice the people were on the phone and the driver) shame on the kitchen for even putting that pizza in a box
  • KE
    K E
    Nov 11, 2025
    5.0
    Pizza is amazingy. Staff is always friendly. Great prices and great taste!
Read more reviews on Google

Frequently Asked Questions About Sammy's Pizzeria

What is the history of Sammy's Pizzeria?

Sammy's Pizzeria is a family-owned business that has been operating for over 60 years, spanning three generations. Sammy Musolino originated the popular "1/2 Tray" of Pizza, a community staple.

Where is Sammy's Pizzeria located?

Sammy's Pizzeria is located at 1400 Hyde Park Blvd, Niagara Falls, NY 14305, USA.