The Pizza Box NY

Reviews

• TT

  Tiffany

  1 day ago
  5.0
  I only write reviews if they are that good or that bad. Let me tell yall something this pizza is so good, it’s not greedy, and you don’t feel a carb overload and stuffed. I’m a small girl and finish a whole small individual Pie. I love the vibes here, owner is super nice. Is it expensive? Yes, but so are those medical bills and co pays. If you are on a health journey and craving pizza this is it! Even if you’re not this is still it! We the people must support private owned businesses! ♥️
• DK

  David Kruta

  4 days ago
  5.0
  We came in with friends and our baby and had no clue how the place worked. Owner saw us trying to make our way to the back, asked if we’d ordered yet, and walked us through the menu without making us feel dumb. Big smiles and a welcoming vibe already. From there it just kept going. She told us what to get, came back to check on us a bunch of times, and at some point handed our baby a onesie - our baby who downed 2 slices of pizza because it was delicious. The staff was also great, checking on us but also shooting the shit with us. Pizza was phenomenal on top of that. Get the pastor if they're offering it. Wrapping it up, the owner brought our kid strawberries. Completely unnecessary. As someone that left NYC after living there for over 15 years, this was an amazing welcome back. I wish I could give this place more than 5 stars. Get here before it blows up.
• ZS

  Zoe Steinsnyder

  Apr 15, 2026
  5.0
  Both dining in and delivery, the pizza is delicious! Though dining is obviously the better experience because of the friendly staff and prime location. The owners are great people and everything about my multiple visits/orders has been nothing short of ideal.
• AP

  Adam Paljieg

  Apr 5, 2026
  5.0
  Fantastic food even better people! We happened to stop by after a pizza tour and were absolutely blown away by the inviting atmosphere, friendly staff, and incredible pizza. The Pizza Box is a true family establishment and we were lucky to be able to talk with both Michael and his son about their experiences with the shop. Michael was so kind in taking time out of his day to talk with the this fellow pizza nerd in depth about his pizza making process and ingredients. It's hard to stand out in the New York pizza scene, but The Pizza Box should be at the top of your list.
• LP

  Louise Puma

  Apr 3, 2026
  5.0
  Had my 32nd birthday at Pizza Box after coming once before on a random night. Truly a slice of pizza heaven in NY. The staff are the kindest and most friendly people I’ve ever met, truly make you feel like an extension of their family and so welcomed. I have a lot of GF and vegan friends and everyone said this is the only pizza they’ve ever had that hasn’t made them feel bloated or gotten a reaction to. The quality of their ingredients is just as amazing as the quality of the staff who own and run The Pizza Box. Truly such a special experience to have had my birthday there and everything they do for the community is so heart warming. Definitely recommend stopping by for a slice and having your event there as well! All my friends had a blast celebrating with the pizza box family for my 32nd and they truly helped bring my vision to life ❤️