Magnolia Bakery

Reviews

• DD

  Danny DC

  1 day ago
  5.0
  What an amazing discovery the banana pudding!!! Extremely recommended! The staff, the muffin, the ice chai latte, and the ice americano made our day! 🥰 Also, there’s a great playground where our daughter enjoys playing.
• JB

  John Bennett

  6 days ago
  2.0
  1) Walk inside store 2) Interrupt worker ignoring me at front-desk packing banana pudding "Excuse me, can I pickup my order" 3) Employee grunts points to other side of store 4) Go to other side of store where employee making boxes back turned to me, "Excuse me, can I pickup my order" 5) Oh, we don't have mini-cupcakes, your order was cancelled 6) Check e-mails, never got cancellation e-mail 7) Somehow walk out without $60 for two pack of mini cupcakes, literally the main thing this store makes
• ES

  Elizabeth Snow

  Apr 11, 2026
  5.0
  It had a nice time strolling into this bakery, they had many dessert options, heavy cake or some lighter snack options. The service was also friendly and sharp, Eli (EE-ly) who served us was pleasant an attentive even when my daughter wasn't sure what she wanted, he made sure she left the bakery happy.
• MF

  Michele Ferraraccio

  Apr 10, 2026
  3.0
  Passo di qui per provare i cupcake, prendo quello red velvet, e quello vaniglia classico, direi che si cupcake ma senza niente di cosi entusiasmante, quello red velvet aveva una certa panna sopra ma non era panna e l'ho tolta un po' avendola troppa, l'altro aveva la loro crema al burro zuccherato che ho tolto perché meglio dire "no al colesterolo ma si a valsoia" ahahahah, comunque prendo anche i muffin, e prendo quello alla zucca dove però si sentiva specialmente la cannella, e poi quello alla banana che era più buono, nonostante amassi la cannella ma in quello della zucca, non si sentiva niente se non la cannella, però entrambi gli impasti erano morbidi e buoni
• PP

  Paayal

  Apr 9, 2026
  5.0
  Loved visiting the original Magnolia Bakery! It has such a charming old-school feel. The atmosphere is cozy and authentic, and it feels like stepping back in time. Definitely worth the visit if you’re in NYC! We got the banana pudding and flourless chocolate cake, and both were absolutely delicious!