Magnolia Bakery

Reviews

• DD

  Di DOk

  4 days ago
  2.0
  I usually stop by in the morning(before work) right when they open, but lately I’ve been a bit disappointed with the banana pudding. The bananas tasted overripe, and taste of cream was not so good, like they might have been from the day before. Overall, everything else is really delicious, so I’ll probably start coming later in the day instead, instead of morning
• MI

  Maya Bar Ilan

  5 days ago
  4.0
  One of New York's most known bakeries, especially famous for their signature banana pudding. They offer 3 sizes of it (S, M or L), and we were 2 people that shared the small one, just as a light snack on the way, as we knew we had to taste it after hearing about it so much from all around the web, as well as from some friends. It was very good, creamy & delicious, but I'm not sure it's really worth the crazy hype around it.
• DS

  Denis S

  Apr 11, 2026
  5.0
  Die Magnolia Bakery hat sich während unseres New York Trips sehr schnell zu einem unserer absoluten Lieblings-Spots entwickelt! Wir waren so begeistert, dass wir uns hier gleich mehrmals mit dem weltberühmten Banana Pudding versorgt haben. Er ist einfach unglaublich cremig, perfekt abgestimmt und macht geradezu süchtig – ein echtes Highlight, das man unbedingt probiert haben muss. Man sollte es aber auf keinen Fall nur bei diesem einen Klassiker belassen: Neben dem legendären Pudding sind auch die fantastischen Kuchen in der Auslage eine absolute Empfehlung! Egal für was man sich entscheidet, man schmeckt die hohe Qualität und die Handwerkskunst bei jedem Bissen. Wer eine Schwäche für hervorragende Süßspeisen hat, kommt an dieser Bäckerei in NYC einfach nicht vorbei. Wir freuen uns schon jetzt auf den nächsten Besuch!
• HH

  HCL

  Apr 5, 2026
  5.0
  So, this place is so great! The location in uper-west side is so delightful, as well as the bakery is great. The cupcakes from magnolia bakery are great. Indeed, they are sometimes green or Yellow, with a great sugary taste, the puffy part under is also very good. As a total, I would love to add that this place is a place to go, as the service is also clean. If one day you are looking for what cookie or what cupcake to buy, go here!
• RK

  Risa Keo

  Mar 30, 2026
  1.0
  Went in to buy couple of carrot cake slices when I noticed the guy behind the counter wiping and cleaning the dessert fridge with dessert still in there. He told me he didn’t have any containers for the cake but that he did have cakes. When I suggested using paper plates, he angrily grabbed the plates with the same wet blue gloves he’d been cleaning with and started cutting the carrot cake — without changing or removing the gloves. It was a little after 930 I hightailed it out of there. I wasn’t about to buy anything after seeing that. It honestly mortified me, especially when I saw another group walk in completely unaware. SMH — forget that carrot or any cakes… management really needs to do better with basic hygiene and food-safety training.

Frequently Asked Questions About Magnolia Bakery