Jonny's Pizza

Reviews

• EK

  Elizabeth Kaufman

  Apr 11, 2026
  5.0
  Daughter and I just spent a week in Rome and were on a quest to find the best pizza. Had some very good ones, but after we shared a slice (“pepperoni Jonny’s way”) we agreed that the best pizza might just be here! We’ll be regular patrons from now on.
• MM

  mia

  Apr 7, 2026
  5.0
  after a long day of traveling the city, johnnys pizza is the perfect place to grab a quick bite! their pizza is DELICIOUS and piping hot when you receive it! definitely recommend eating here, and the pricing is definitely affordable!
• SS

  shimmeringpath

  Apr 6, 2026
  4.0
  Pretty decent slice on the corner of Orchard Street and Stanton. The crust is thin but also just a little chewy (which i like. ) I felt the sauce had a bit of a spicy taste too (but not too much.) Also, you can ask them to grate fresh Parmesan on your slice at no extra cost. I think you can ask for a hot honey drizzle too , though i didn't get that . Unfortunately there are no seats in here so that's the only drawback. But it's probably the best slice in this immediate area if you happen to be nearby. Tasty pizza.
• AS

  Aby Soumare

  Mar 29, 2026
  4.0
  $8.71 for a slice of cheese pizza + hot honey with a diet coke. The crust was okay, and the hot honey added a nice sweet aftertaste. There isn’t a lot of cheese, but that left the bottom nicely crispy. Little steep for what it is, honestly. If it was cheaper, I’d really enjoy this place. My friend got vodka pepperoni with burrata and a diet coke, ran her $13.60 (with a $1.2 tip) for everything. Her slice was super good, and she got a good amount of pepperoni and burrata on it. No chairs, no bathroom. The music is good, and the windows are nice and big. We got here as soon as it opened, so it was pretty empty. I can imagine how crazy it gets when it hits dinner time! Not a huge space.
• HH

  HIB

  Mar 20, 2026
  1.0
  Do NOT order for delivery, you won't receive food & you will have no way to contact the business. I ordered directly through their website to support a small business. After ordering, I noticed that it was going to be 1.5-2 hour wait -- my mistake on not clocking this but OK. I received a message that the order was going to be delivered third party by Uber Eats. Thought this was strange so I decided to see if they were on Uber Eats - they are, offering BOGO for the items I ordered, as well as a sub one hour delivery time. Great to support a business directly, receive a worse deal, and over double the wait time. But OK, I'll wait. I never ended up receiving my food and the order was cancelled over 2.5 hours later. I live 1.5 miles from the restaurant. There is no way to get in contact with Jonny's because their phone line is either dead or faking busy, so you cannot get through. They do not respond to emails. They do not respond to the SMS messages. They do not respond to Instagram DM. Uber gives you the runaround for contact b/c they are third party delivery partners, rather than direct. Pretty insane to run a place with delivery and have no way to get in contact with the business. No idea how the pizza is, but can say that the service is trash.

Frequently Asked Questions About Jonny's Pizza