John's Pizzeria of Times Square

Reviews

• SG

  simon goulty

  1 day ago
  2.0
  Don’t bother used to be great place and vibe Now pizza is lukewarm warm and the service is pathetic. And expensive for what you get So if you want good pizza, there’s a lot better to be had
• RR

  RGerst

  Apr 14, 2026
  5.0
  Man findet leicht Platz weil es riesig ist, scheint ein altes Theater oder so gewesen zu sein - tolle Atmosphäre. Das Essen ist gut und kommt schnell, das Personal war durchweg hilfsbereit. Das Essen schmeckte uns gut (wenngleich wir die „echten“ Italiener in Europa bevorzugen) und die Preise sind der Lage angemessen.
• SW

  Sean W

  Apr 7, 2026
  2.0
  Went for dinner today Tuesday 04/07/26. Arrived at 4:45 and was told it would be a 15-20 minute wait for our party of 5. No problem. I asked the hostess if she needed my name and she said no. After waiting 30 minutes and seeing three other parties seated in front of us (2 parties of 4 and 1 party of 5 that arrived at least 10min after us) it was obvious the hostess forgot about us. When I asked the hostess why a different party of five was seated ahead of us she asked “what’s your name?” I reminded her she said she didn’t need my name. I spoke up to gentleman wearing a gray blazer who seemed like a manager and he said we would be seated next. After being seated we waited about 10 minutes before our server even asked what we wanted to drink. We ordered drinks and food all together as soon as the server came over because we knew it was going to be a rough dinner service and we just wanted to eat and get out of there. Expect total chaos and a very long wait if you’re planning to eat here.
• KO

  kay ortiz

  Apr 5, 2026
  2.0
  Party of 5 - we asked for an open table with more room . We were seated on the end of the top level stairs . Servers bumping into us , the other table guest pushing into our chair with Their butts brushing our table . The larger open section - "we don't use that now ". Food. Pizza crust was bubbly and ok , taste was salty like a thin wet cardboard box . Presentation looks yummy and pretty . Tastes overall dry , salty , see thru thinner center with no fold . Building very unique . Overall waste of ingredients so much potential . The photographer going table to table to sell you a group photo was a stupid and tacky idea . Waiting for our order was fast Checking out was fast . Pizza from the side of the street way better in taste and value . With drinks for 5 of us a large cheese an a large 2 topping with around $130
• LC

  Lenise Coleman

  Apr 2, 2026
  1.0
  This place serves terrible pizza! Visiting from Chicago and wanted to taste New York pizza. Ordered and had it delivered to my hotel and the crust was completely burnt. From the delivery driver and the person taking the order, both were rude. Very disappointed with the pizza , could have ordered Pizza Hut , it would’ve tasted the same.