Stretch Pizza

Reviews

• KP

  Kimberly Peng

  2 days ago
  5.0
  The pizzas are banging! The Metro is a good go-to! The Al Pastor is an interesting one and very tasty! The dough was crispy with chew. Savored every slice and dipped that crust in the dips! The tiny chocolate chip cookies were a perfect sweet to finish it all off. Will definitely be back for more!
• MS

  Millie Shi

  Nov 16, 2025
  4.0
  Nothing fancy but all solid Food - meatball sliders, Al pastor pizza. Good actual taco flavor, nice crust Drinks - Englishman and A Lil R&R, both decent. We’d just come from Clemente Bar before this and call me crazy but I preferred the Englishman here Staff is awesome and super friendly
• SS

  Sabena Singh

  Nov 6, 2025
  5.0
  Stretch Pizza has very flavorful pizzas. This is the work of the celebrated Chef Wylie DuFresne. Some time ago, the restaurant started serving slices all week till 5 pm. Having had a tasty slice at their branch in The Hugh, I came here to see the variety. Now this is the first time that I ordered two slices. The first was the plain which was top notch. Thin crust, flaky and tender till the last bite. Then I ordered the Sicilian with pepperoni. I counted twenty slices on this rectangular pizza. The pepperoni comes from a pasture raised farm and as I thoughtfully chewed I could taste the umami flavor of this cured salami. Each bite was ambrosial. Team Stretch made my lunch memorable. Jose at the bar who took my order conversed with me. He was both professional and amiable. Having eaten here a few times since they opened, I now look forward to having slices. The next one is the mushroom pesto although I wish the Nellie would also be a slice - one day!
• RS

  reeves “mm” ss

  Oct 23, 2025
  5.0
  The pepperoni slices were superb! Wylie’s dough really hits the mark! Reminds me of the crust at Difara’s pizza way out in Brooklyn on the Q! I am going say that this may just be the perfect ny pepperoni slice! It’s a better version of Joe’s pizza. Surprised there is not a line for slices as there was none at 12:30pm on thursday. Perhaps it was just timing. The restaurant design is a bit confusing though. Is this a bar? why are the pizza ovens in the back out of site? I just find the whole layout to not line up with my idea of a pizza joint. But perhaps thats me!
• MC

  Moody Cat

  Oct 17, 2025
  3.0
  This is a very casual sit down place much like an Applebees but with better food. Won’t hurt your wallet, either. The bar is nice and big and somewhat comfortable with good foot rests but seats are stools with no back rests so not too good to relax here after a tiring day. But really bright, fun ambiance to experience with friends. I was hoping with a name called Stretch Pizza, pizza crust wud be super thin but no dice since it’s only moderately thin ala usual street slice. In fact, other than it’s a 12 inch pie, this very much feels and tastes like your average street pizza with moderately thin, crispy crust, moderate amount of cheese, and pretty good sauce. I prefer lots of good cheese that I have to fight with cheese with each bite but no dice here. I normally finish 12 inch pie easily but struggling here since crust not super thin the way I like it. Also, those rims not light or airy either. Not sure I’ll be back. It’s very mid and definitely better than Pizza Hut nearby but it’s just not amazing. As an avid pizza aficionado looking for city’s best pizza it’s a umm, eh for me. I also walked many blocks to try this when best pizza in city are mostly in downtown area.

Frequently Asked Questions About Stretch Pizza