Papa Johns Pizza

3.5
245 reviews
Get DirectionsCallWebsite

Business Details

1709 AMSTERDAM AVE, New York, NY
10031, United States
(212) 281-7272
https://locations.papajohns.com/united-states/ny/10031/new-york/1709-amsterdam-ave
GoogleFacebookInstagramTwitter

About

Pizza RestaurantPapa John's
At Papa Johns Pizza in New York, NY, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it's our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best New York pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in New York or stop by 1709 AMSTERDAM AVE for carryout to order the best pizza in New York, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!

Details

  • DeliveryAvailable

Location

Papa Johns Pizza
1709 AMSTERDAM AVE, New York, NY
10031, United States

Hours

Reviews

3.5
245 reviews
5 stars
96
4 stars
52
3 stars
27
2 stars
9
1 star
61

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Service Issues

Numerous customers reported poor service, including long wait times, incorrect orders, and unresponsive staff.

Food Quality

Mixed reviews on food quality; while some praised the pizza as delicious and fresh, others experienced issues like food poisoning and incorrect toppings.

Customer Experience

Several customers expressed dissatisfaction with the overall customer experience, citing rude staff and lack of resolution for complaints.

Delivery Problems

Many reviews highlighted issues with delivery, including late arrivals, missing items, and incorrect charges.

Positive Staff Interactions

Despite the negative feedback, some customers noted friendly and helpful staff, particularly during in-store visits.
  • SS
    Sebastian Santander
    Nov 3, 2025
    1.0
    Horrible service
  • VB
    Veronica Brahms
    Oct 17, 2025
    5.0
    Papa John's is my go to delish extra cheesy yummy pizzas to enjoy.There are so many varieties to choose from with sodas,breadsticks,desserts,dipping sauces The toppings are yummy to add on your pizzas.My pizzas are always hot and fresh with flavor.The staff is friendly and great.The place is clean and you can smell the pizzas baking in the oven.Thr crust is thin and made to order with stuffed garlic and many delish vegetables to bite into your favorite pizzas.The prices are very reasonable to enjoy pizzas for every occasion.
  • AF
    ALEXANDER FLORENTINO
    Sep 4, 2025
    5.0
    My small cheese pizza was awesome and the staff were super helpful and friendly—not sure of the other staff member’s name I spoke with, but Pablo and he were both awesomely great! My only beef: and this is of course at no fault of the staff—the difference between carry-out and delivery was from $6 to $18. Man, the staff were so nice and I do have a bit of an addiction to Papa John’s pizza, so I’m sure I’ll order again but only when I’m certain I can pick it up—the fees for delivery are completely outrageous. But again, everything was just as ordered, arrived quickly and was hot and very delicious.
  • RA
    roshana anderson
    Apr 4, 2019
    5.0
    Best pizza chicken and green peppers yum yum. Place is fast and clean
Read more reviews on Google

Frequently Asked Questions About Papa Johns Pizza

What are the delivery hours for Papa Johns Pizza at 1709 Amsterdam Ave, New York?

Delivery is available Monday to Thursday and Sunday from 10:00 AM to 2:00 AM, and Friday to Saturday from 10:00 AM to 3:00 AM.

Can I order takeout from Papa Johns Pizza, and what are the takeout hours?

Yes, you can order takeout Monday to Thursday and Sunday from 10:00 AM to 1:40 AM, and Friday to Saturday from 10:00 AM to 2:40 AM.