Mastro's Steakhouse

Reviews

• SP

  Stephanie Paris

  2 days ago
  2.0
  There was so much weed smoking in the kitchen. Everytime the kitchen door opened, it smelled like weed. Horrible. Then they ask do u want ur steak with truffle butter, but don’t tell you it’s 16.00 extra! 16.00 for truffle butter???
• RR

  Rover

  Dec 29, 2025
  5.0
  We sat downstairs and they made sure they were aware of our after dinner show plans. They timed everything perfectly and Mark and his team took great care of us. Food was delicious - we got steaks, fish and several sides. We have two teenagers and they enjoyed it as well. It was a wonderful experience and I would recommend. I would have taken a photo of our food, but I was so into the relaxing atmosphere that I forgot to take out my phone!
• RM

  Rori Madden

  Dec 25, 2025
  5.0
  As longtime regulars of the original Mastro’s in Scottsdale, (all 3 locations) our expectations are always high, and Mastro’s NYC exceeded every single one of them. From the moment we walked in, the service was warm, welcoming, and elevated. Brian, the wine director, went out of his way to check in and make sure everything was perfect, and our server Sebastian delivered the kind of attentive, genuine service you rarely see anymore. The food was flawless!! The perfectly cooked steaks, incredible sides, and desserts somehow topped it all off. Every detail felt thoughtful and consistent with the Mastro’s standard we know and love, while still having that special New York energy. We left saying this was our favorite Mastro’s experience ever. Huge thank-you to Brian and Sebastian. ✨
• TM

  Tim Mundy

  Dec 23, 2025
  5.0
  Fantastic restaurant with great food and great atmosphere. My wife had twin lobster tails and she kept raving about how well done they were. I had a filet mignon that was seasoned and cooked perfectly; very tender. The white cheddar mac & cheese was tremendous. Our cocktails were very well done. We didn’t have room for dessert, but I’m sure it would have been very good. Our server Ronnie was very helpful and attentive. The overall experience was worth every penny. Highly recommended.
• SF

  Steven L. Finkelstein

  Dec 22, 2025
  2.0
  I have eaten at several Maestro's in other states and have ALWAYS been impressed by the atmosphere & first class service. Unfortunately, that was NOT the case when entertaining my family at home in New York City. With an advance reservation, my party was greeted by the hosts and told there were several holiday parties going on and could not sit us at the bar to order drinks -prior to our reservation. They actually asked us to leave & come back. After voicing our displeasure, the manager "allowed" us to sit at the bar and spend money on drinks. Then they sat us at horrible location on the lower level next to an elevator that the wait staff used to bring dishes/glasses & chairs up/ down throughout the dinner. While the food was good, the experience, atmosphere and MOST importantly the reception was UNACCEPTABLE. This took place on Thursday, December 11th. A memorable evening for the wrong reasons.

Frequently Asked Questions About Mastro's Steakhouse