While many customers enjoyed the food, several reviews noted that some dishes were bland, uninspired, or not prepared well.
Service
Customer service received mixed reviews; while some praised the friendly and attentive staff, others reported slow service and issues with order accuracy.
Atmosphere
The diner is appreciated for its cozy, retro vibe, creating a warm and welcoming environment for diners.
Pricing
Some customers found the prices to be reasonable, while others felt that certain items were overpriced or not worth the cost.
AM
Allen McKenzie
3 days ago
4.0
The name Diner made us stop for breakfast. The cornbeef hash was outstanding, the 5 towers omelet was good also.
DO
Daniel Olivo
3 days ago
1.0
wouldn't know how the food is lol it never came via grubhub
MB
Mic Blizz
Jan 4, 2026
5.0
Always great service and top quality food. I come for the Irish breakfast. Always so delicious.
DR
Dominique Restagno
Dec 21, 2025
5.0
Love this diner. Provides a warm homey feel with excellent, friendly service and really good food too!
Frequently Asked Questions About Yesterday's Diner
What are the regular operating hours of Yesterday's Diner?
Yesterday's Diner is open from 6 AM to 8 PM Monday through Wednesday, and Sunday. It operates 24 hours on Thursday, Friday, and Saturday.
Does Yesterday's Diner offer delivery and pickup services?
Yes, Yesterday's Diner provides both in-store pickup and delivery services.
Where is Yesterday's Diner located?
Yesterday's Diner is located at 443 Jericho Turnpike, New Hyde Park, NY 11040, USA.
What type of cuisine and dining experience does Yesterday's Diner offer?
Yesterday's Diner serves American cuisine including breakfast, brunch, sandwiches, hamburgers, and vegetarian options. It is also a family-friendly diner and caters events.
What is the price range at Yesterday's Diner?
The price range at Yesterday's Diner is categorized as moderate (TWO).
Can I view Yesterday's Diner menu and place orders online?
Yes, you can view the menu and place orders online at https://yesterdays-diner.com/menu.
What are the takeout hours at Yesterday's Diner?
Takeout is available from 6 AM to 8 PM Monday through Wednesday and Sunday, and 24 hours on Thursday, Friday, and Saturday.
What nearby places can I visit before or after dining at Yesterday's Diner?
Nearby places of interest include Gold Coast Maserati for automotive services, Hollywood DJs for entertainment, and Umberto's for Italian dining.
Are there nearby coffee shops around Yesterday's Diner?
Yes, Dunkin' is located nearby, offering coffee, donuts, and smoothies, perfect for a quick beverage before or after your meal at Yesterday's Diner.
What nearby health services are accessible from Yesterday's Diner?
Nearby health-related services include Tooth Time Dental Studio, Straight Set Orthodontics, and New Hyde Park Animal Hospital if you need dental or veterinary care.