Mille Luci Pizzeria

Reviews

• LM

  Lo Mein

  Feb 22, 2026
  4.0
  Some of the best pizza I’ve had! I can taste the freshness , and the basil was a great touch . I do wish the edges weren’t as burnt, & also that they made it clear they don’t accept cash when I placed my order, but it worked out. Definitely a new favorite!
• XB

  Xiomara Beltre

  Feb 16, 2026
  5.0
  Wow what a great experience! This pizza was delicious! We ordered vodka, margarita and Snow White! Each was delicious! We go to alot of pizza spots and this one is one we will definitely come back to. The ingredients were fresh and straight from Italy as the owner shared and showed us. We also had the Joe’s Special Dessert and it was the perfect ending to our meal. The waiter Lucas was friendly and made our time a great one. Joseph the owner came and spoke to us welcoming us.
• KN

  Kristina Nicholson

  Feb 15, 2026
  5.0
  This authentic Italian restaurant and wine bar in New City is truly a gem. From the moment you walk in, you can feel that it’s a family-owned business built on love, pride, and genuine hospitality. The owner is incredibly warm and attentive, making every guest feel like part of the family. You can tell how much heart and passion goes into every detail — from the food to the service to the cozy atmosphere. The pizzas are phenomenal — perfectly light, airy, and beautifully crisp with that authentic Italian texture that doesn’t leave you feeling heavy. Every bite tastes fresh and thoughtfully crafted. The garlic zeppoles are hands down the best bite-sized indulgence — golden, fluffy, and absolutely addictive when paired with their rich, flavorful marinara sauce (you’ll definitely want extra!). I tried their beef meatballs for the first time and was blown away. They are incredibly tender, packed with flavor, and clearly made with high-quality ingredients and traditional technique. You can taste the authenticity in every dish. Their wine selection is impressive and thoughtfully curated, complementing the menu perfectly. The staff is welcoming, attentive, and professional without ever feeling rushed. The restaurant itself is spotless, and the atmosphere is warm, intimate, and cozy — perfect for date night, family dinner, or simply enjoying a great meal with friends. I appreciate everything about this place and will absolutely be returning. If you’re looking for authentic Italian food made with heart, this is it.
• CW

  Cody W

  Feb 9, 2026
  5.0
  From the moment I walked in for the first time, Joe and his son Joe made me feel like family. The hospitality alone would bring me back, but the pizza? Next level. I honestly can’t put into words how good it is. The quality of the ingredients is unreal you can taste the freshness in every bite. They’re always incredibly accommodating with any special requests, which just shows how much they care about their customers. At this point, their pizza has officially claimed the top spot as my weekly cheat meal go to and I look forward to it every single time. There's no one else in Rockland that even comes close to their pizza!🍕🔥
• KM

  Ken Hansraj, M.D.

  Jan 31, 2026
  5.0
  ★★★★★ An Exceptional Dining Experience in New City Mille Luci is, without exaggeration, one of the finest dining experiences in Rockland County. From the moment you walk in, the restaurant strikes a rare balance between warmth and sophistication—inviting without being casual, refined without feeling pretentious. The food is outstanding, rooted in authentic flavors and executed with precision. Each dish reflects a clear respect for ingredients, technique, and presentation. The menu offers depth and intention rather than excess, and everything arrives thoughtfully plated and perfectly cooked. You can immediately tell that the kitchen operates with pride and consistency, not shortcuts. Equally impressive is the service, which is attentive, knowledgeable, and genuinely welcoming. The staff understands the menu well, offers thoughtful recommendations, and times each course appropriately—never rushed, never neglected. It’s the kind of service that elevates the entire meal without drawing attention to itself. The ambiance deserves special mention. Milei Leu has created a space that feels intimate yet polished, ideal for a special occasion, a quiet dinner, or an upscale night out without traveling into the city. The atmosphere encourages conversation and enjoyment, and it’s clear that care has been taken in every detail of the dining environment. In a time when many restaurants aim to be trendy or loud, Milei Leu stands out by being excellent, consistent, and authentic. It is a destination restaurant for New City—one that reflects culinary seriousness and genuine hospitality. Highly recommended. This is a place you return to not just for a meal, but for the experience.

Frequently Asked Questions About Mille Luci Pizzeria