Business Details
About
Pizza Restaurant
Details
- DeliveryAvailable
- TakeoutAvailable
- Curbside pickupAvailable
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.3
154 reviews
5 stars
106
4 stars
19
3 stars
7
2 stars
9
1 star
13
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Food Quality
Customers praised the pizza and empanadas for their taste and quality, with many considering it the best in the area.
Service Issues
Several reviews highlighted inconsistent service, including long wait times for orders and mistakes with online orders.
Customer Experience
While many customers appreciated the friendly staff and welcoming atmosphere, some reported negative experiences due to poor service or food quality.
Menu Variety
The menu offers a wide range of options, including unique empanadas and specialty pizzas, which customers enjoyed.
Delivery Problems
Multiple customers experienced issues with delivery times and order accuracy, leading to dissatisfaction.
- UMumberto marinoNov 14, 20255.0Pizza top! Great quality, great varietals! 100% approved. PS: born in Italy and definitely approved ! 😀
- MPMagdeline PenaNov 13, 20251.0Catania’s used to be one of my families favorite place to go to and about a week ago we ordered a pie and it wasn’t as good as before, today we decided to give it a second chance and the pizza was very salty. Called the pizzeria and explained that for some reason it was salty, hoping that they could remake it and all they said was “our sauce is not salty”. Never going back again.
- DDDeshaun DavisNov 11, 20254.0The pizza was pretty good. The garlic bread could have had more garlic and cooked longer but the experience was definitely good being it was my first time there. I know my son loved it.
- AGAmelia GallagherNov 7, 20255.0Amazing food service and staff. Best cookies around ! The skateboards at 2nd Nature loved all the food .
- NNNNov 5, 20251.0Never had a bad experience until today 11/5/25 around 3pm (check ur cameras) I was the only one inside I can tell no manger or supervisor wasn’t around just workers 2 ladies having their meals and the one worker by himself (photo) he told me “can you wait few mins and I am busy alone” I’m like okay I can wait (when a worker says that I understand u know but) I was waiting for 5-10 mins then I noticed hiding in the corner on his phone watching a show or movie obviously he forgot about me I was sitting where he saw me and I get up and I told him can I order now or I still have to wait he said “oh I forgot” I wanted to leave so bad but I was hungry I said “u told me to wait so I did but you lied to me so I want to order please” I made it obvious I was upset and he didn’t apologize nor anything I left the store around 3:18-3:19pm Next time I’ll leave if it happens again
Frequently Asked Questions About Catania's Pizza - Mohegan Lake
What are the regular hours of operation for Catania's Pizza - Mohegan Lake?
Catania's Pizza - Mohegan Lake is open every day from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM.
Does Catania's Pizza - Mohegan Lake offer delivery services?
Yes, Catania's Pizza offers delivery service.
Can I pick up my order at Catania's Pizza - Mohegan Lake?
Yes, in-store pickup is available at Catania's Pizza - Mohegan Lake.
What are the takeout hours for Catania's Pizza - Mohegan Lake?
Takeout orders can be placed from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM daily.
Where is Catania's Pizza - Mohegan Lake located?
It is located at 1821 E Main St, Mohegan Lake, NY 10547, USA.
What types of cuisine does Catania's Pizza - Mohegan Lake serve?
They serve pizza, Italian, American dishes, chicken wings, seafood, and salads.
How can I view the menu or place an order online for Catania's Pizza - Mohegan Lake?
You can view the menu and place orders at https://catanias-pizzeria.com/menu.
Are there any other restaurants near Catania's Pizza - Mohegan Lake worth visiting?
Yes, nearby dining options include Awesome Empanadas, Taco Bell, IHOP, Baskin-Robbins, Cafe Pizzazz, and Benvenuto II offering a variety of cuisines.
Which nearby stores could be convenient to visit before or after dining at Catania's Pizza?
You might visit nearby stores such as T-Mobile, Sprint Store for mobile needs, Niles Floors & Blinds for home shopping, or Roses From the Garden for flowers.
Are there any nearby services for beauty or wellness close to Catania's Pizza?
Yes, nearby beauty and wellness services include Details Day Spa, Hair By Mirella, Salon V, Blooming Nails and Spa, and Haven Hair Studio.