FATBOYSBBQ

Reviews

• SM

  S M

  4 days ago
  1.0
  Absolutely awful!!! The place is clean but dingy. The lady was rude. Nothing in our order what correct. The Fat Boys sauce is a weird mustard base and horrible. Do not eat here!!!
• KS

  Kate Stanford

  6 days ago
  5.0
  Fred is amazing and super friendly. Makes the best meat. The best “funny fat guy “. Food is always consistently delicious and great portions for your money. Menu has so many options there is something for everyone.
• DD

  Deborah Davidson

  Apr 12, 2026
  1.0
  Was here a few months ago and it was awesome. Ordered last night and it was terrible. Ordered 2 dinners of the jumbo shrimp. It was not jumbo was overcooked so was hard. No barbecue sauce some disgusting yellow/ orange sauce. Also ordered pull pork. Everything was cold. Beans were tasteless. Mac and cheese was not good. And put cheese on the pulled pork. Small portions for the price
• SY

  Scarlett yates

  Mar 26, 2026
  5.0
  Went here with my dad and we ended up meeting the owner, Freddie, who was incredibly welcoming from the start. You can tell he genuinely cares about the food and the people coming in. Everything we had was honestly amazing. My dad got the brisket with collard greens and mac and cheese, and the brisket was super tender and packed with flavor. I had the BBQ chicken sandwich with mac and cheese, and it did not disappoint. The homemade sauce he uses is unreal, easily one of the best parts of the meal. The cornbread (shoutout to Maria) was so good I basically stole it off my dad’s plate and didn’t share at all. They also have gluten free options, you really can find something for everyone, even if you don’t eat meat. Service was excellent, food came out hot and fresh, and the whole experience just felt solid from start to finish. It’s a little tucked away in Manorville, but absolutely worth going out of your way for. They also have food trucks, which would honestly be perfect for events or even weddings. If you’re looking for real BBQ on Long Island, this is the spot. There’s a ton on the menu and it was hard to choose. Already planning to go back for the chicken and waffles. Couldn’t recommend it more. Freddie’s hospitality alone makes it a 10/10.
• KC

  Kiara Collazo

  Mar 22, 2026
  1.0
  My husband and I wanted to try something new and it was so disappointing for starters we placed an order for 6:15 he got there 10 minutes earlier and the food was not ready at all not only that but for the cost of the food I would expect to have flavor once we received the order and got home they did not pack the corn bread with our order which was included in the meal instead gave us fries I would’ve at least like to know if you do not have something at least let us know or ask what we would like beside it since it’s not available the food has no flavor whatsoever the jumbo BBQ shrimp had no Bbq Sauce and was not jumbo at all the Mac and cheese is just melted cheese no seasoning the only thing that was okay was the burnt tips that actually had BBQ sauce and the potato salad would not be returning and a waste of money

Frequently Asked Questions About FATBOYSBBQ