Benny's Pizza

Reviews

• AS

  Agnes Sabonsolin

  Jan 4, 2026
  5.0
  Easily one of my fave food in NY. I have already been there 3x since arriving in the US. 😍
• CA

  Cj Anthony

  Dec 11, 2025
  1.0
  Pizza sucks, service sucks, workers are very rude and the owner does not care about his customers. Told me to come back to fight at 9pm after work which I will demonstrate what happens with my registered hands to people who think they are big. Your a pizza worker at 40 years old. Let that sink in.
• SS

  Suave

  Nov 22, 2025
  5.0
  Been coming to Bennys for over a year now going into 2 , they’ve never dropped the ball on quality once. This location truly delivers on New York style pizza , every bite taste like home & that’s what keeps me coming back. Definitely recommend trying vodka squares or slices !
• CP

  christian pulchan

  Nov 20, 2025
  5.0
  I love coming to this pizzeria! Pizzas are delicious and taste amazing with just the right amount of everything and a thin crispy crust! The staff is very friendly and helpful and treat u like family, Benny Jr always hooks us up with some Zeppoles when we buy pizza pies n stuff & the environment is always clean and spacious enough to enjoy a meal there. Ever since my girlfriend and I came here we cant stop coming back! There's no other pizzeria that compares once u try it! They also have a large selections of other Calzones and specialty pizzas, also the first pizza shop I seen with a saladmenu! There's so many different things they have here that u just have to check out the menu yourself! I also wanted to add that its one of the few pizza shops with parmesan cheese toppings here and the pizza hot sauce here is delicious and has one of a kind taste you cant find in majority of pizza shops around. I highly recommend u try it yourself and you'll see why we can't stop coming back lol!
• CE

  cindy equite

  Nov 20, 2025
  5.0
  Ive been coming to Bennys since High school. I moved away from Queens and forgot about this place. Me and my boyfriend recently came back because I remembered how delicious it was and I can truly say that the pizza has gotten BETTER !! I feel like so many shops lose that authentic nyc slice but this place has always had it and NEVER LOST IT LOL !! No kidding we come here AT LEAST once a week. We no longer look for pizza any where else lol the atmosphere is amazing. The worker at the front Benny Jr ll is great, remembers us, always greets us and always knows what we want. He has given us complimentary zeppoles it makes us feel appreciated. Im fully convinced he even recognizes my voice when we call in and order LOL! Employees/owners recognizing their customers gives it such an even more spectacular experience. Thank you guys so much. We love the food. We love the employees. We love the atmosphere. If youre deciding where to get pizza LOOK NO FURTHER!! Every single thing we have ordered from here has never disappointed. Try the hot sauce on your pizza idk if its homemade but that sauce???? Something we have never tried before🔥🔥 my bf never looked at another pizza shop again. We are hooked! 😅

Frequently Asked Questions About Benny's Pizza