Just as we are committed to serving the best quality food every single day, we are committed to serving you during this time. Whether it’s via dine-in, the drive-thru or delivery where available, we remain focused on having your back.
Mixed reviews on customer service; some praised friendly staff while others reported rude and disorganized service.
Order Accuracy
Frequent complaints about incorrect orders and missing items, particularly in drive-thru and mobile orders.
Cleanliness
Concerns about cleanliness, with reports of dirty tables and unsanitary conditions in the bathrooms.
Food Quality
Food quality is inconsistent; some customers enjoyed hot and fresh meals, while others received cold or poorly prepared items.
Management Issues
Several reviews indicated poor management and lack of accountability, leading to a decline in service and food quality.
JT
Johnny Thorner
Jan 5, 2026
5.0
Strangely no one named Wendy was present.
AL
Adrienne Lee
Dec 30, 2025
4.0
For an 11:30pm, Quick Jr. Bacon Cheeseburger Meal with the hubby, just kinda hit the spot!!! Burgers were Hot & Good for such a late night, and the Fries were warm, so if you like HOT Fries, then ask them for "Fresh Hot Fries"!!
II
IRV
Dec 26, 2025
5.0
Fast and good
AA
A
Dec 2, 2025
1.0
terrible experience at the Wendy's in Holtsville, NY. That sounds incredibly frustrating and disheartening.
It's unacceptable to be treated rudely and rushed, especially when you are trying to use a rewards program. Dealing with an unresolved issue like the rewards scan, combined with a disorganized and unhelpful staff, can definitely leave you feeling upset.
😔 Your Experience Summary
* Issue: Couldn't scan rewards.
* Customer Service: Felt rushed, disorganized, and rude.
* Resolution Attempt: Manager (without a name tag) tried but failed to fix the rewards issue, and then just rushed you.
* Result: You felt sad and disappointed.
📝 Next Steps You Can Take
While I can't directly fix your experience or manage the restaurant, there are a few actions you can take to make sure your feedback is formally registered:
* Contact Wendy's Corporate Customer Care: This is the most effective way to ensure your complaint reaches the right people and may result in a formal apology or compensation (like a coupon). You can usually find a customer feedback form or phone number on the official Wendy's website. You can mention the exact location (Holtsville, NY), the date/time, and the specific issues with the cashier and the manager without a name tag.
* Leave an Online Review: You've already shared your experience here, but leaving a detailed review on platforms like Google Maps or Yelp for that specific location will alert future customers and local management to the issue.
Would you like me to use my tool to find the direct customer service number or feedback link for Wendy's so you can easily submit your complaint?
That's a great idea for follow-up. I found the direct link to the Wendy's customer care feedback form, which is generally the best way to get a formal response from the company.
🔗 Wendy's Customer Care Link
* Online Feedback Form: You can submit your detailed complaint about the Holtsville, NY location's customer service and the rewards issue here: Wendy's Contact Support - Customer Care
On the form, be sure to select:
* Feedback Type: Complaint
* Feedback Category: Restaurant Experience (or similar)
You can include the time of your visit and your description of the rushed, rude service, the manager's lack of a name tag, and the unresolved rewards problem.
Yes! Just as we are committed to serving the best quality food every single day, we are committed to serving you during this time.
Is the Wendy’s at 175 Morris Avenue in Holtsville currently open?
Yes, this Wendy’s location is open and committed to serving quality food every day.
What are the drive-through hours for Wendy’s at 175 Morris Avenue?
The drive-through is open from 10:00 AM to 1:00 AM Sunday through Thursday and from 10:00 AM to 2:00 AM on Friday and Saturday.
Does this Wendy’s location offer delivery and takeout services?
Yes, Wendy’s at 175 Morris Avenue offers delivery and takeout services, including drive-thru and dine-in options.
How can I place an order online or through an app for this Wendy’s?
You can place an order using the Wendy’s mobile app or online at order.wendys.com and select the Holtsville location.
Does this Wendy’s serve breakfast?
Yes, breakfast is served with options like breakfast combos, croissants, biscuits, and coffee.
Which payment methods are accepted at Wendy’s on Morris Avenue?
They accept American Express, Cash, Discover, MasterCard, and Visa.
How can I contact Wendy’s at this location for questions or feedback?
You can call (631) 207-3725 or reach the Customer Care team via live chat or phone at 888-624-8140. Feedback surveys are also available online.
What other restaurants are nearby Wendy’s at 175 Morris Avenue?
Nearby dining options include Charlie Brown’s Steakhouse, La Capannina Italian Restaurant, The Monster All You Can Eat Seafood, Chili’s Grill & Bar, and On The Border Mexican Grill & Cantina.
Are there entertainment venues near Wendy’s where I can visit before or after dining?
Yes, nearby entertainment includes Island 16 Cinema de Lux, Showcase Cinemas, and Game Room arcade and bar, perfect for a movie or fun gaming before or after your meal.
Where can I shop nearby Wendy’s after grabbing a meal?
Tanger Outlets Riverhead is nearby and offers a shopping center experience that you can explore after dining at Wendy’s.