MK
Mohsin Khan
Apr 19, 2026
Many places in Hicksville, but this one stands out for the quality of food, ambience and exquisite service. Definitely my #1 spot now especially for someone who droves 60miles and came all the way from New Haven county, CT.
I was introduced to Mehfil by a friend. We catered for an event here, and ever since, it’s become a regular weekly or bi-weekly visit to the location because the food is consistently delicious. My family absolutely loves the food and the friendly service. I highly recommend Mehfil to friends and family. It’s definitely worth the visit.
MR
Muzzamal Riaz
Apr 13, 2026
Their food is very delicious, providing all Pakistani tastes from Egg burger to Mutton karahi. Friendly environment, good staff with best service. How to forget about Mehfil restaurant’s Location that is best in the locality with a big parking place. No doubt they got the best Pakistani Chef✌🏼
Amazing experience at Mehfil! The atmosphere was warm and inviting and the staff was so sweet and welcoming. The curry was incredibly rich flavorful and perfectly spiced and they have a great selection of appetizers and a solid kids menu. Highly recommend the beef kebab karahi and the garlic naan as both were absolutely delicious. Everything was fresh well prepared and full of flavor. Can’t wait to come back!
I had a disappointing experience at Mehfil Restaurant in Long Island. We ordered three dishes, including the karahi (recommended by a staff member) and haleem, and overall I would rate the food 2/5—definitely not up to expectations in taste or quality.
The service was just okay, but the biggest concern was cleanliness. I noticed cockroaches in the premises, which is completely unacceptable and ruined the experience.
On top of that, they added an 18% service charge plus a credit card fee (even though I used a debit card), along with tax. For three dishes, the total came out to over $130, which felt unreasonable given the experience.
Overall, not recommended unless major improvements are made. Hire an authentic Pakistani chef.