At Homemade Taqueria we take pride in the freshness of our cooking. Our tacos are always served on a warm, fresh corn tortilla and our entire menu features delicious authentic Mexican food. From our favorite tacos to our mouth-watering platters, we will bring to your table a perfect meal in a friendly environment to share and enjoy with family and friends. Come visit us and have a homemade meal with us. Because if it’s not Homemade, it’s not the best!
Many customers praised the food for being fresh, flavorful, and delicious, particularly the tacos and quesadillas, while some expressed disappointment with bland or poorly seasoned dishes.
Service Issues
Several reviews highlighted problems with service, including long wait times for food, issues with delivery, and automatic gratuity charges that customers found misleading.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's atmosphere received positive remarks for being clean and inviting, although some noted it was small and more suited for takeout.
Value for Money
While some customers felt the prices were reasonable for the quality and portion sizes, others criticized the high costs and additional fees for gratuity and card payments.
GH
George Hay
1 day ago
1.0
So disappointing. This place can never get it right. Chips are always crushed to pieces when ordering nachos to go. How is one supposed to eat this? I have to go wash off my phone now after typing this.
DB
Danna B
2 days ago
1.0
AVOID. First experience is nice then they play games. Suddenly 20 minimum. 2 hours wait. And they hang up on you and play game after game. No! You lost a local customer. And you're gonna lose more. There are SO many restaurants here, it's so competitive, what a BAD experience unlike ANYTHING I have ever had service wise. A joke!
PORQUERIA
PP
Paola Poliak
2 days ago
1.0
While the food was decent, the service was extremely disappointing. The lady was rude and behaved unprofessionally, making personal comments with other employees behind the counter, which made the atmosphere uncomfortable.
During our meal, we placed an order to-go, but no one notified us when it was ready. After a long wait, I had to inquire myself, only to be told it had been ready for some time. She handed it over without any apology or acknowledgment.
To add to the frustration, a 20% gratuity was automatically added to the bill. Given the poor service we received, this felt unfair and undeserved. Unfortunately, the service alone ruined what could have been a decent experience, and I would not return.
HH
Hillary
4 days ago
1.0
There was a hair in my food that I had to literally dig out. Gross!
AA
A A
Dec 26, 2025
5.0
Love their shrimp quesadillas. Made with fresh tortillas always.
Frequently Asked Questions About Homemade Taqueria Forest Hills
What are the operating hours of Homemade Taqueria Forest Hills?
Homemade Taqueria Forest Hills is open from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM Monday through Thursday and Sunday, and from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM on Friday and Saturday.
Does Homemade Taqueria Forest Hills offer delivery and pickup services?
Yes, the restaurant offers both in-store pickup and delivery services.
What types of meals does Homemade Taqueria Forest Hills serve?
They serve lunch and dinner meals featuring authentic Mexican cuisine, including tacos, burritos, enchiladas, and more.
What payment methods are accepted at Homemade Taqueria Forest Hills?
The restaurant accepts cash, Mastercard, and Visa payment options.
Where is Homemade Taqueria Forest Hills located?
It is located at 72-36 Austin St, Forest Hills, NY 11375, United States.
Where can I view the menu or place an order online for Homemade Taqueria Forest Hills?
You can view the menu and place orders online at https://homemadetaqueria.com/menu.
What nearby dining options are available around Homemade Taqueria Forest Hills?
Nearby dining options include Gnocchi Bella (Italian cafe), Chip City (bakery and desserts), Sushi Time (Japanese and sushi restaurant), Bonfire Grill (American restaurant), and La Boulangerie (bakery and coffee shop). You can enjoy a variety of cuisines before or after visiting Homemade Taqueria.
Are there nearby shops or services close to Homemade Taqueria Forest Hills?
Yes, nearby are Hills Shoppe (tobacco shop and lounge), Austin Organic Market (organic grocery store), CTown Supermarkets (supermarket), Manny's Cleaners (dry cleaning), and Austin Optics (optometrist and eyewear store) for convenient shopping and services.
Is there easy transportation access near Homemade Taqueria Forest Hills?
While specific transit stations are not listed, the central location on Austin St in Forest Hills near various shops and restaurants implies good accessibility. You may want to explore local transit options to reach the restaurant easily.
Which communities does Homemade Taqueria Forest Hills serve for delivery?
They serve the surrounding cities of West Hempstead, Uniondale, Garden City, Franklin Square, Hempstead, Lake Success, and Mineola for delivery services.