Customers appreciate the fun and lively atmosphere, making it a great place to hang out and watch sports.
Service
While many reviews praise the attentive and friendly staff, some customers experienced slow service or felt ignored.
Food Quality
Feedback on food quality is mixed; while some dishes like wings and burgers receive high praise, others are criticized for being mediocre or poorly prepared.
Event Hosting
The venue is well-regarded for hosting private events, with many customers noting the accommodating staff and pleasant settings.
Beer Selection
The establishment boasts a large and diverse selection of beers, which is frequently highlighted as a positive aspect.
CC
Crispy Crispy
3 days ago
5.0
Great place, quick service and food. Great for watching sports games. My favorite are the wings, tacos, or burgers. Loud atmosphere but still talk able.
VS
Vince S
Nov 15, 2025
4.0
Great place to watch all the football games on Sunday afternoon. The atmosphere is fantastic, the service is excellent, and the wings are freaking awesome!! Plenty of meat on them. You'll need a lot of napkins. When are you all looking for a great place to watch the Sunday football action, check out Croxley ales in Farmingdale
TA
Touqeer Ahmed
Nov 10, 2025
5.0
Great place for large groups. I recommend the Mahi Mahi tacos. Awesome customer service.
RC
Ray Catania
Nov 7, 2025
5.0
The French dip is 🔥🔥🔥. The service is better. Our waiter was awesome. Thank you Justin for the exceptional service.
SS
S Shapiro
Oct 29, 2025
5.0
I had my 40th birthday party in the Garden Room at Croxley’s and everything was PERFECT! The room itself is really beautiful. The bathrooms are separate from that of the restaurant/bar, we had our own bar, and there was plenty of room to mingle and dance. Our maitre’d was so easy to work with and the bartender and waitstaff were attentive and great too. I wish I could go back to have my party all over again! I wouldn’t change a thing.
Frequently Asked Questions About Croxley's Farmingdale
What are the general opening hours of Croxley's Farmingdale?
Croxley's Farmingdale is open from 12:00 PM to 12:00 AM Monday to Thursday, until 2:00 AM on Fridays and Saturdays, and closes at 11:00 PM on Sundays.
When is the kitchen at Croxley's Farmingdale open?
The kitchen is open from 12:00 PM to 11:00 PM on Monday and Tuesday; until midnight Wednesday and Thursday; until 1:00 AM on Friday and Saturday; and closes at 10:00 PM on Sunday.
Where is Croxley's Farmingdale located?
Croxley's Farmingdale is located at 190 Main Street, Farmingdale, NY 11735, USA.
How can I contact Croxley's Farmingdale?
You can contact Croxley's Farmingdale by phone at +1 516-293-7700.
Where can I find the menu for Croxley's Farmingdale?
The menu for Croxley's Farmingdale is available online at https://www.croxley.com/farmingdale-menu/.
What type of establishment is Croxley's Farmingdale?
Croxley's Farmingdale is categorized as a Bar & Grill, offering a casual dining and bar experience.
Are there interesting places to visit near Croxley's Farmingdale?
Yes, nearby you can visit The Downtown, known for its arts, entertainment, and historic significance, which makes for a great place to explore before or after dining at Croxley's Farmingdale.
What other dining options are near Croxley's Farmingdale?
Nearby dining options include Croxley's Ale House - Farmingdale, Croxley's The Garden, Tiny Thai Restaurant, and Tre Scalini, providing a variety of American, Thai, and Italian cuisines.
Are there any bars or lounges close to Croxley's Farmingdale for after-dinner drinks?
Yes, nearby bars and lounges include Vintage Wine Bar and Bistro, Wild Wild West Saloon, X BAR, and Lithology Brewing Company where you can enjoy drinks after your meal.
Can I combine a visit to Croxley's Farmingdale with other local amenities?
Absolutely. In addition to dining at Croxley's Farmingdale, you can visit nearby places such as One-Stop Grocery Shop for shopping, Prestige Barber Shop or Janes Nails for personal care, and ZUZU Soft Serve for dessert.