Customers consistently praised the friendly and attentive service from the staff, highlighting specific employees like Poly and Marcela.
Food Quality
The bagels received high marks for being fresh and delicious, with many customers noting the variety and customization options available.
Atmosphere
The establishment is described as welcoming and clean, providing a pleasant dining experience for customers.
Customer Loyalty
Many reviews indicate that customers are repeat visitors, often traveling from afar to enjoy the bagels and service.
CR
Christian Rivera
4 days ago
5.0
Nicest people and greatest bagels. Always get them for my team at work and they always say they are the best.
MM
Matt M
Feb 1, 2026
1.0
The food here isn’t bad, for a Long Island bagel spot it’s about average. The prices are very high. The biggest issue here is the staff. They constantly forget things, are very rude, and just seem upset to be working. Given the amount of options I’d go somewhere else for a slightly better price and much better service.
MS
Maureen Spencer
Jan 28, 2026
5.0
The ladies and gentlemen behind the counter are AMAZING….
always so friendly….
Hey Friend….!!!
Lol
KP
Karin Prins
Jan 20, 2026
5.0
Best service! The girls are the best! Bagels are amazing! So many options!
LG
Laurie guigliano
Jan 19, 2026
5.0
My name is Laurie The Bagel Place is the BEST Josh /Donna and the rest of the staff are friendly & always helpful I give them a 5 star