Location.com logo
Brand Certified

Riley Fibbers

4.6
(354 reviews)

Business Details

148 Carleton Ave, East Islip, NY
11730, United States
(631) 581-3300
https://rileyfibbers.com/

About

PubRestaurantSports BarAmerican Restaurant
"Cozy little pub in the heart of East Islip. Delicious food, great drinks, and a warm friendly staff. Great for family and friends. Come join us and see what we are all about!"

Details

  • Dine-inAvailable
  • DeliveryNot available
  • TakeoutAvailable
  • Requires reservationsNot available

Location

Riley Fibbers
148 Carleton Ave, East Islip, NY
11730, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.6
354 reviews
5 stars
257
4 stars
70
3 stars
16
2 stars
2
1 star
9
  • GS
    Gissell Sanchez
    Feb 15, 2026
    1.0
    I came in on Valentine’s Day with no expectations …. just hoping for a quick, easy little treat. The bar was empty, so I thought that would mean good service. We were greeted by a gentleman who took our order. I ordered the appetizer of tenders and fries and asked, if possible, to have the tenders tossed in wing sauce and to upcharge the fries to cheese fries with bacon. I was under the impression that this wasn’t an issue, and I appreciated that my meal initially came out as requested. Unfortunately, the bacon on top of the fries was extremely disappointing. It was burnt, crumb-like pieces, very oily, and had a gritty texture. It honestly smelled off. It seemed like leftover scraps rather than freshly prepared bacon. I would have completely understood if they had simply said they were out of bacon … that would have been far preferable to serving something that didn’t feel edible.I sent the whole meal back and asked for the rest of our meal to be wrapped up to go. My husband’s chili was only lukewarm, but he chose not to say anything further given how disappointing the experience had already been. What added to the frustration was how the situation was handled. The bartender who originally greeted us and dropped off the food never came back to check on the issue. Instead, he sent the female bartender he was working with to finish assisting us. I would understand if his shift wand done but w He was just in the back and left her take car of us. She was sweet, understanding, and apologetic, and I appreciated her professionalism. I don’t normally write negative reviews because I understand that mistakes happen. However, the quality of the food. Particularly the bacon and the lack of follow-up from the original bartender really turned what was supposed to be a simple Valentine’s treat into a disappointing experience. It upset me enough to feel the need to share this feedback. I’ve also added a picture of the napkin I originally started to put the burnt bacon. Once I realized that it was gritty and so greasy I sent it back.
  • CM
    Chriz McVain
    Dec 15, 2025
    5.0
    Place is an absolute gem. Very good food. Even great service. Will be coming back soon.
  • JM
    John Mendon
    Dec 10, 2025
    1.0
    Serve u drinks then say ur too drunk i was just standin not botherin any1 unless they can read minds or somethin no reason to kick you out thas how they run clubs in latin america kick u out just to mess wit u
  • AD
    A D
    Nov 30, 2025
    5.0
    Friendly place, where you feel welcomed as soon as you walk through the door.
  • SS
    Stingray
    Nov 12, 2025
    5.0
    Dropped by and ordered Wings xtra crispy and a Reuben sandwich! The wings were unbelievable! ( Best I had in a long while) Reuben was incredible too ! Service was spot on! Great Lunch Indeed! Will definitely be coming back soon! Thank You!

Brand Certified Facts from Riley Fibbers

This information is certified by Riley Fibbers and published from the brand's official system of record. Data is distributed through an enterprise-grade knowledge management platform. Learn more about our data sources
Certified March 15, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
  • Address
  • Categories
  • Geo coordinates
  • Legal business name
  • Hours of operation
  • Phone number
  • Official website
Syndication Network
Approved business data is pushed to 100+ publishers, including: