Mixed reviews on food quality; some dishes praised while others criticized for being bland or poorly prepared.
Service Issues
Inconsistent service reported, with some customers experiencing long waits and inattentive staff.
Atmosphere
Generally positive feedback on the restaurant's atmosphere and lake views, though some found it too loud.
Reservation Challenges
Customers advised to make reservations; some reported issues with seating despite having reservations.
Staff Friendliness
Many reviews highlighted friendly and attentive staff, particularly specific servers who made a positive impact.
SS
Samantha Staring
Nov 13, 2025
1.0
I have been coming to Rocky’s for one reason and that is to get excellent service with some laughs from Mary. The food is not good! Very inconsistent for years now ( since they opened basically) 50/50 it’s a gamble on what you will get so I come because of Mary and before that it was Joe at bar keeps bringing me back, atmosphere is stunning. However the water smells and tastes like sulfur and they charge for bottled water. (Not good). That should be a courtesy. There also are some new people (girls) wait staff who roll eyes and hang by the hostess stand, not sure what is going on with Rocky’s lately but it is making me think twice about coming up North when I can stay locally and go out. Why isn't Mary on the bar when she usually is? The last 2 times we came in she wasn’t, the vibe is different she was always on the bar Thursday or at least on Fridays . Nope just some more new rude staff? These girls are not the best bartenders. Be Better Do Better! I want to keep supporting.
MK
Mr Kade (Kaid)
Nov 12, 2025
5.0
The price is well worth the food greatest food I’ve had in a while. Tastes great is always cooked right never had a bad experience here nice staff even the chefs have great attitudes. Perfect for big family’s or dates with that special someone you’ll find yourself going back trust me worth the trip
SL
Susan Laliberte
Nov 10, 2025
5.0
So nice and clean,means were.huge as.well as the cesser salad, chicken and greens I highly recommend !
KS
Kelsey Sue
Nov 9, 2025
5.0
It was my first time there and the restaurant was gorgeous, the food was amazing and the staff was excellent. I found my new favorite restaurant to go eat at!
KA
Kimberly Aichner
Oct 23, 2025
5.0
My husband and I went to Rocky’s last month. It is located on Hinckley Reservoir near a campground. We found it with Google maps. There was plenty of parking on the side and in front. They asked us if we had reservations. We did not but they seated us right away. It is advisable to have reservations for better seating. They have seating with a view of the lake.
I ordered the broiled haddock. My husband ordered the stuffed haddock. My meal was very good. My husband did not like the sauce they put over the stuffed haddock. He said it tasted fishy and ruined the meal. All of the other food was very good. I saw other people’s meals coming out and evening looked good. Customers were making comments about how good the food was. Many were regulars.
Our waitress returned at the end of our meal and she asked about his meal and offered us both free dessert.
All of the waitresses were attentive to the customers. Taking plates, offering drink refills or whatever was needed. They clearly worked as a team and it was a nice environment as a result of their team work.
I works recommend this restaurant.
I’m adding some photos.
Frequently Asked Questions About Rocky's on The Lake
Does Rocky's on The Lake accept reservations?
Yes, Rocky's on The Lake accepts reservations, which can be made online through their reservation link.
What are the brunch hours at Rocky's on The Lake?
Brunch at Rocky's on The Lake is served only on Sundays from 10:00 AM to 2:00 PM.
When is the kitchen open for dinner at Rocky's on The Lake?
The kitchen is open Wednesday through Friday from 4:00 PM to 9:00 PM, Saturday from 11:30 AM to 9:00 PM, and Sunday from 10:00 AM to 5:30 PM.
What meals are served at Rocky's on The Lake?
Rocky's on The Lake serves lunch, brunch, dinner, and happy hour.
Where is Rocky's on The Lake located?
Rocky's on The Lake is located at 438 Mac Arthur Rd, Cold Brook, NY 13324, on Hinckley Lake in the Adirondacks of New York.
What cuisine does Rocky's on The Lake offer?
They offer Italian cuisine with a bar and pizzeria experience, also categorized as an American restaurant and sports bar.
What payment options are accepted at Rocky's on The Lake?
They accept American Express, Cash, Check, Discover, MasterCard, and Visa.
Does Rocky's on The Lake offer pickup and delivery services?
Yes, they offer in-store pickup and curbside pickup services.
What nearby accommodations can guests use when visiting Rocky's on The Lake?
Guests can stay at The Kuyahoora Lodge and Resort, which is a nearby hotel and resort close to Rocky's on The Lake.
What recreational spots are near Rocky's on The Lake to visit before or after dining?
Trails End Campground and Mobile Home Park and Trail's End at Hinckley Lake are nearby campgrounds, and Hinckley Lake itself is a scenic lake, all great places to enjoy outdoor activities around your visit.