Tony's Brooklyn Pizza

Reviews

• HH

  H.

  Apr 14, 2026
  1.0
  First time ordering here. This will certainly be my last. I ordered a well done pepperoni pizza off of grubhub and this how it came. The pizza was cold to the touch. The box for pizza was not sealed properly either. The garlic knots were not fresh, they were hard. I’ll never order here again. $25 for this BS.
• SS

  Sandra P S

  Apr 10, 2026
  5.0
  Absolutely remarkable. The most funny thing about this place is he fact that this is a building you can rent in monopoly Brooklyn edition. The food has lots of variety and is amazing. Not that busy during rush hour and overall a great environment view outside is nice too. :D
• MA

  Melissa Ahearn

  Apr 1, 2026
  5.0
  Staff is so nice, you can tell it’s a family atmosphere. And the pizza was delicious.
• DD

  Daniel

  Mar 16, 2026
  4.0
  Tonys is so much better than Carmines. Not even close. That being said the Sicilian pizza (my favorite) is undercooked almost every time, with a very distinct layer of goo under the cheese (that is different from soggy pizza). Fix that and its 5 star.
• RO

  Rodrigo O

  Mar 14, 2026
  1.0
  I just got a chicken roll from them flavor was good but they only gave me about a half a chicken roll and then one of the ends had only bread no chicken 😂